The Winter Greens Trifecta: Kale, Collards and Spinach

 

Vates kale outdoors in our winter garden.
Photo Bridget Aleshire

Here are three types of winter-hardy leafy greens to feed you through the winter. In central Virginia, it is too late to sow any greens for this winter. If you live in zone 9 or warmer, where you could still sow spinach and maybe collards and kale in December. Spinach sowings can be made until Oct 15 in South Carolina and Nov 15 in Louisiana. This post is to help with planning for next year.

Kale Varieties

Red Russian kale in our hoophouse
Photo Pam Dawling

There are two main types of kale, Brassica oleracea and Brassica napus. Oleracea types can have more cold tolerance and go somewhat dormant in cold weather, which lets the kale survive to regrow when the weather improves in the spring. Our outdoor kale, for both fall and spring planting, is Vates Dwarf Blue Scotch Curled, an oleracea type, the most cold-tolerant we have found. We prefer the curly-leafed kind over the flat-leafed as it holds up better against wilting and wind damage. We have not been successful indoors or out with dinosaur kales (also oleracea) as they harbor too many aphids in the curled-back edges of the leaves.

The napus types continue to grow at lower temperatures than oleaceae do, but they can’t stand such cold temperatures. The special spring kale varieties such as Hanover Salad, and the Russian and Siberian kales, are all napus types. White Russian and Red Russian kales do very well in our winter hoophouse but do not survive our winters outdoors. They are more productive and better flavored in our winter hoophouse than Vates.

Collard varieties

Morris Heading Collards. We plant 3 rows in a 4ft wide bed. Photo Kathryn Simmons

Collards have risen in popularity in recent years, partly thanks to the book Collards: A Southern Tradition from Seed to Table by Ed Davis and John Morgan, two geographers who traveled the South gathering information, stories, and seeds from collard growers both black and white. Their seed collection inspired the Heirloom Collard Project to preserve some Southern foodways. Seed Savers Exchange, Ujamaa Seeds and Southern Exposure Seed Exchange have been growing sixty varieties to preserve the genetic diversity of collards and increase the availability of seeds.

Collards: A Southern Tradition from Seed to Table

Our long-time favorite collards are Morris Heading, with slightly savoyed leaves, finishing with a head later in spring. More recently, we have been enchanted by some with beautiful colors, such as Alabama Blue and Nancy Malone Wheat Purple Collards. We’ve also grown Georgia. Northerners seem to prefer smaller-leafed collard varieties such as Champion, Flash, and Top Bunch. Green Glaze and Big Daddy Greasy Green collards have shiny leaves more resistant to caterpillar attacks.

Spinach varieties

Reflect spinach in the open got damaged but not killed at -9F.
Photo Pam Dawling

For people who love OP vegetables, the Bloomsdale varieties —Abundant, Winter, and Long-Standing —are reliable. However, for bolt-resistance and productivity, we go with the hybrids. On the East Coast, bubbly savoyed spinach varieties are preferred, while on the West Coast, smooth-leaved ones are popular. We experimented with smooth-leaved spinach, thinking it would be easier to clean, and it probably is. The disadvantage is that it wilts very quickly after harvest and needs to be picked and chilled promptly. Space is a good smooth-leaved variety.

For a dark-leaved savoy type, with good cold tolerance and good bolt resistance, we compared Acadia, Avon, Escalade and Reflect. Acadia (45d) and Escalade (43d) had the best early fall harvests and best bolt resistance in our trial of overwintering. They are both rated highly for baby leaf production, if that’s what you do. Spinach is cold tolerant down to 10°F (–12°C).

Sowing

Brassica seedlings under ProtekNet in August.
Photo Pam Dawling

Brassicas germinate very well at high temperatures: the ideal is 77°F–85°F (25°C–30°C), and 95°F (35°C) is still OK. Given enough water, the seedlings will emerge in 4.5 days at the low end of this range, and at the top in only 3 days. The third week of June is a good time to start sowing fall brassicas in our region. We use an outdoor nursery seedbed and bare-root transplants for brassicas. https://www.sustainablemarketfarming.com/2017/01/10/bare-root-transplants/

For the seedbeds, we use insect netting (ProtekNet) on wire hoops—good airflow is vital. If you use flats, it can help to have them on benches in an enclosed shadehouse, or outdoors, above the 3′ (1 m) height flea beetles can jump.

Young spinach seedlings.
Photo Pam Dawling

Spinach needs much cooler conditions, and we wait till September and direct sow. Eight weeks before the first fall frost date is a good time to start planting spinach again, if it’s not too hot.  Spinach comes up quickest at 59°F–86°F (15°C–30°C). It makes up for lost time by maturing in just 50 days from sowing. The flavor of spinach is sweetest and nuttiest once the weather cools. Unless overcrowded (by other spinach or by weeds), or underwatered, spinach will not bolt until spring daylight reaches 14 hours.

Our second fall sowing is usually September 20–30, and these overwinter small and do not reach harvestable size until early spring. This planting will bolt in the spring at a date between the first fall sowing and the spring sowings. In climates colder than Zone 7, make the fall sowings earlier in order to have adequate growth before hard freezes, sowing as soon as soil temperatures are cool enough for germination, perhaps 77°F (25°C).

Amounts to grow for overwintering

Beds after rain,
Photo Wren Vile

We transplant our dwarf kale at 12″ (30 cm) apart, 4 rows in a 4′ (1.2 m) bed. We plant collards at 18″ (46 cm) in-row spacing. For a hundred enthusiastic vegetable eaters, in spring we grow 1,080′ (330 m) of kale, and 540′ (165 m) of collards. We harvest kale and collards by the leaf, for multiple harvests.

Weeding rowcovered spinach in winter.
Photo Wren Vile

We typically plant 5 rows of spinach on our 4′ (1.2 m)-wide raised beds, and sow 1,080′ (330 m) to feed 100 people all winter (the same amount as we sow of kale). We always grow collards, kale, and spinach in raised beds. We grow spinach on 6″ (15 cm) spacing in-row.

Transplanting

Flats of transplants in our cold frame ready for transplanting.
Pam Dawling

We aim to transplant most brassicas at four true leaves (3–4 weeks after sowing). It is better to transplant crops at a younger age in hot weather than you would in spring because larger plants can wilt from high transpiration losses. If it is necessary to use older plants to fill gaps, we pinch off a few of the lower leaves to reduce their water needs.

We plant fall kale by a mixed direct sow/transplant method that allows for the possibility of patchy germination, and requires less watering than if we direct sowed it all, and less time than transplanting them all. We sow 2 beds on each of three dates in August, with 4 rows 10″ (25 cm) apart. Later we carefully thin them, leaving one plant every foot (30 cm). We use the carefully dug thinnings from those beds to fill gaps and to plant more beds, at the same spacing.

Crop care

We do not normally rowcover winter kale and collards, as they will survive without. In harsh winters, we lose the collards. Using rowcover would keep crops in better condition later into the winter, but we have found the fibers stuck in the curly-leaved kale. In areas where continuous snow cover doesn’t happen, rowcover on hoops will protect spinach. If you use rowcover without hoops, the abrasion of the fabric on the leaves causes damage, and they are more likely to freeze to the fabric if you have wet weather followed by freezing nights. Hoops help create a nice microclimate, noticeable when you harvest.

Rowcover rolling with crank handle.
Photo Rodale Institute

Pest control

Use rowcover or netting to keep pests off the plants while they are small. Pests are less of a problem in winter. We are also lucky enough to have the naturally occurring wasp parasite of cabbage worms, the Braconid wasp Cotesia species, which are found as small cottony white or yellowish oval cocoons in groups on brassica leaves. If you find Cotesia cocoons, you can leave them in the field over winter. Or you could collect leaves with cocoons in late fall and store them at 32°F–34°F (0°C–1°C) until spring. Hopefully no one will clean out your fridge without asking.

Diseases

Details for dealing with several diseases and a chart of commercially available compounds can be found in Organic Production and IPM Guide for Cole Crops, by Abby Seaman, NYS IPM Program, and in the ATTRA publication, Cole Crops and Other Brassicas: Organic Production, by M. Guerena.

White Russian kale ready for harvest.
Photo Pam Dawling

Harvest

We usually have about 7 beds each of overwinter kale and spinach and can pick one each day in October, November, February, and March. All three greens will make some growth whenever the temperature is above about 40°F (5°C), so we can also make occasional harvests in December and January. Kale, collards and spinach last until they bolt in early May, sometimes April for spinach.

Spinach after and before harvesting.
Photo Pam Dawling

We use a marker flag to show which bed to harvest next, moving it to the next bed after each harvest. We harvest kale and collards by snapping off the largest leaves. There are three main ways to harvest spinach:

  1. Harvest by the leaf, with scissors. This has the advantage of producing an attractive product —all whole leaves. I believe it is also the least damaging to the plant and likely to give the highest total yield over the life of the plant. It can be rather slow, depending on the skill of the harvester.
  2. The buzz-cut method is much faster, and the plants live to carry on producing more. Gather the leaves and cut them all 1″ (2.5 cm) above the crown. The plants do take longer to recover from buzz-cutting than from leaf harvesting. If you are making a salad mix, the fact that the leaves are cut might not matter. This is a good method when time is at a premium. If your plants are frost damaged, with yellow-white patches, this method might not work as well as leaf-harvesting as you might have to do lots of sorting.
  3. The final method is the single harvest: cut the plants, then till in the crop residue and start again. This is the quickest method and produces the most beautiful spinach, but obviously it isn’t suitable if you hope to overwinter your spinach as it kills the goose that lays the golden eggs, and it will be too late in the year to resow. Season extension into winter relies on extending the harvest period by keeping plants alive and productive for multiple harvests.

More information

Workhorse Crops for April includes the links to each month’s post in that series (lots of kale)

Success with winter kale and collards earlier this year covered crop requirements, rotations, systems for growing these crops, timing, planning, sowing, transplanting, crop care and harvest.

Success with Spinach for Fall, Winter and Spring includes info on varieties. presprouting, floating Speedling flats of spinach on water in the daytime, and growing bare-root transplants.

Sowing kale, finishing planting cabbage, more on zipper spidershas info about kale varieties.

Planting kale, catching up on weeding and reading

Sowing beets, radishes and kale, transplanting cabbage.

Farming and Gardening in a Changing Climate

 

A crew of gardeners planting garlic in our East Garden. Photo Twin Oaks Community

Yesterday and today we have been planting garlic. This is the latest date we have planted garlic in at least 30 years, and maybe ever. We were waiting for the soil temperature to drop to 50F as a morning reading. October and most of November so far have been very warm and dry here. If planted into soil too warm in the fall, garlic makes too much top growth before cold weather slows it down, and suffers too much die-back from the cold.

I’ve written before about garlic and the planting temperature.

The warmer temperatures have affected our crops in other ways too. Our kale and spinach are growing really well outdoors, as is our last lettuce bed.

Tokyo bekana in our hoophouse.
Photo Twin Oaks Community

We have a hoophouse harvest schedule finely crafted over 20 years to maximise the food we get from that delightful space, and not waste food by growing too much. Our harvest schedule tells us what to expect when. We grow some fast-growing greens we can eat in November, and some slower ones to feed us all through the winter until mid-April. And some heading greens, pak choy and napa cabbage, to eat during December and January, the times of slow growth. Whole plants of Tokyo bekana are usually eaten in November, as they bolt if left until December.

Our strategy includes being sure to only harvest the leafy greens at a sustainable pace. This is the vegetable equivalent of not killing the goose that lays the golden eggs. Having those big heading greens in December and January slows down our rate of harvesting leaves of spinach and Asian greens.

Spinach after and before harvesting. “Eight for Later”
Photo Pam Dawling

We have a mnemonic “Eight for Later”, which means leave at least 8 small central leaves on each plant of spinach, tatsoi, yukina savoy, kale, mizuna, etc. Chard and senposai can survive on “Six for Later” as their leaves are big.

Our fall hoophouse crops get planted in September and October.

Winter Hoophouse Harvest Dates

  • October: beet greens, radishes, spinach, tatsoi.
  • From November onwards: As October plus arugula, brassica salad mix, chard, lettuce leaves, mizuna and scallions.
  • From December: as November plus kale, senposai, turnips, and Yukina Savoy.
  • From January: as December
  • During December: whole plants of Tokyo Bekana, Maruba Santoh.
  • During January: heads of Chinese cabbage, pak choy, tatsoi.

Having the big heading crops in December and January gets us through the slow-growth period.

Most loose-leaf crops last until mid-April or later.

A flower stem on a bolting pak choy plant in our hoophouse 20 Nov 2024. Photo Pam Dawling

This year we already have giant Tokyo bekana, pak choy and Blues Chinese cabbage. The pak choy is bolting and will not be feeding us in January!

Our previously successful planting and harvesting schedule is getting a shake-up. Last fall and this year too, we tried to cram in more crops, in the spaces we didn’t need until mid-November or December. These catch crops need to be fast growing, and finding things that are fast growing in November and December is challenging. Small leafy greens do well, although we also strive to get some beets. (A failure with beets has the back-up success of yielding beet greens, so all is not lost.)

Beet seedlings in 2023, when we put new baseboards and plastic on our hoophouse. This year we tried allowing a longer period for the beets to develop, but then we didn’t thin them enough. . . Photo Pam Dawling (We’re very happy with the metal baseboards!)

Although we know that beets get stunted if not promptly singled, we didn’t get to all of them in time. And the truth is, we are so busy in October with bed prep and planting, that it is hard to find time for singling beets! We might decide to try again next year, with heightened awareness about thinning/singling, or we might go for leafy crops only.

So that’s the vegetable side of life. Meanwhile, the manager of our dairy herd reports that she has had an impossible time maintaining milk yields, because cows either didn’t get pregnant, or did, but then reabsorbed the calf fetus. Our vet says other livestock farmers have had the same trouble: it’s just been plain too hot. And the hot weather running late into the fall means that the poor creatures are panting away in their already-thick winter coats. I wondered why they were lurking in the shade of the solar arrays, even in November. I have choices about what clothes I wear, but the cattle don’t.

I suppose we could invest in portable shade canopies or mister systems, or try Brahman cows – the ones with humps on their backs. Brahmans are an American breed of zebuine-taurine hybrid beef cattle, bred in the US from 1885 using cattle originally from India. I believe at least one farm in Virginia keeps them, including cows for milking. They are heat-tolerant but less cold-tolerant. They don’t sound like an easy option. Expensive, slow to become productive. Shade sounds easier. Not sure how well misters would work in a climate as humid as ours.

Our Blues Chinese cabbage in the hoophouse are already reaching full size. Unlikely they will wait until January to be harvested then. Photo Pam Dawling

I’m only a concerned consumer and fellow-community member, as far as dairy and meat products go, and my main attention is on the vegetable crops. Our hoophouse crew is a small group of experienced growers who are self-starters and good communicators. We take one or more whole days each a week and run things as we think best, guided by a task list we have drawn up and the discussions we have at our weekly crew meeting. We keep careful records and pay attention to what’s happening in there. Currently I’m trying to ID a small flighty moth that is brown with creamy white bars and spots. It flies up from the senposai and turnips. If anyone knows, or has an idea, please leave a comment.

What can you do if fall sowings fail?

 

A successful outdoor bed of young Vates kale Photo Kathryn Simmons

Not everything works out as we hope it will. That’s one reason we grow lots of different crops, trial new varieties, sow a bit more than we need, and make contingency plans in case something goes wrong. Enough crops will produce a harvest, so it won’t be total disaster.

There are many paths to failure: old seed not germinating, soil too wet or too dry and seed not germinating, pests such as cutworms and diseases such as damping off felling our seedlings, and human error. Sometimes we forget to water, to open the greenhouse, or to close up the insect netting.  Sometimes the weather is all wrong: the wind blows the netting or rowcover off in the night; we get a hurricane dumping a lot of rain at once; a late hot spell fries everything while we are away for the weekend. Bad things happen to good growers! What can we do?

Sprouting seeds before sowing is a way to success in hot or very cold weather.
Photo Pam Dawling

First, we can be well-prepared

Ensure, in good time, that you have enough of the seeds you need, including enough to resow if that’s what you need to do. Ensure the seed is not too old, and that you have stored it in cool, dark, dry conditions since it arrived in spring. Ensure you have the insect netting or rowcover you’ll need, flats, labels and markers. Ensure your plan is in place and fits your dreams as closely as possible.

Have a good place to grow your plants, whether you are doing that indoors or out. Good soil, compost, sunlight, protection from winds. Raised beds drain faster than flat ground. Bare-root transplants can make deeper roots, and won’t need watering as many times a day. Plug flats or soil blocks are easiest to transplant, and will suffer less set back from transplant shock.

Brassica seedlings under ProtekNet in August.
Photo Pam Dawling

In the fall, a delay in sowing date makes a lot more difference than it does in spring. In fall, the day length is getting shorter and temperatures are cooling. It will take later-sown seeds longer to provide a harvest than earlier-sown ones – don’t delay! In fall a delay of one day in sowing date can lead to a delay of a week in harvest date!

Second, we’ll be ready to resow if needed

Stay one step ahead. Know what you will do next if Plan A doesn’t work. Include a resow date written in to your planting schedule, to ensure you waste no time. Check the soil temperature and know when your seedlings should emerge. If they are not there, resow right away, in new flats, or outdoors in furrows between the first rows, if you have no spare space. If the first rows do come up, you can hoe off the second ones.

In this post, I’m mostly writing about transplanted crops. Direct-sown crops could perhaps be resown, or you may be able to use transplants to fill gaps. Your transplants could be the same or different. Our normal plan for fall kale is to sow beds, two at a time, then use carefully dug plants from rows that are well-packed to fill out sparse rows. This year we are using kale to fill out failed broccoli rows too.

For me, a schedule to resow is Plan B. Consider a different location or method this time. One year we reached Plan D, and sowed seeds in plug flats in the hoophouse (more sheltered, daily attention) rather than outdoors in our nursery seedbed.

Mid-October emergency back-up seedlings for the hoophouse.
Photo Pam Dawling

Third, have contingency plans for misfortune

If a later sowing is going to leave you without crops for a while when you need them, sow a catch crop. A catch crop is a fast-growing vegetable that makes use of a spare space to produce a quick harvest. Asian greens offer the most choices. See my blog series Asian Greens for the Month. (This link to April’s post is your gateway into all 12 posts.) We have taken to sowing tatsoi (45 days to maturity) or Tokyo bekana (also 45 days to maturity) in our hoophouse in beds destined for later planted crops. We tried 56-day beets, but found they are considerably slower in colder weather. Leafy greens or radishes are fastest.

This year, we have some Tokyo bekana outdoors, to mix with a lettuce shortfall for salads. Our lettuce did not germinate well for a couple of weeks in August, meaning in mid-September we are short of lettuce.

Consider substituting an entirely different crop, if resowing seems doomed (or you don’t have seed on hand). Choose a faster-maturing crop if you want to catch up, or a more cold-hardy one if your harvests will be later into the winter. See my blog series Cooking Greens of the Month. The link takes you to October, from where you can delve into other months.

This fall we have had trouble with our kale and broccoli starts, but great success with senposai and Yukina savoy. Both delicious and fast. For fall harvests, sensposai is ready a mere 40 days from sowing, or 10 days longer if you disturbed it and transplanted, as we do. Depending on your winter climate zone, you may have time to sow for growing in a hoophouse (zone 6 or warmer), or outdoors (zone 8?). If you had a cabbage disaster, try fast-growing senposai.

Consult my chart of Winter-Kill Temperatures of Cold-Hardy Vegetables, to find a suitable crop.

Fourth, search for transplants ready to pop in the soil

Ask around, maybe a nearby grower has spare (and if they don’t, you can at least commiserate!) Perhaps you can buy starts, either locally or by mail. Shipped plants can work better than you fear, but will also push up your costs.

Or trade or buy in some storage crops to compensate.

Fifth, be better prepared next year!

Write down what went wrong, why you think that happened, and a few ideas of how to do better next year. File the information where you can easily find it next year, or better yet, incorporate your ideas into your planning for the next growing season.

Filler greens: short rows of Tokyo bekana, Yukina Savoy and senposai used to fill gaps in the winter hoophouse.
Photo Pam Dawling

Success with winter kale and collards

Alabama Blue collards.
Credit Southern Exposure Seed Exchange

July/August is the time we sow kale and collards for overwintering. (My whole Cooking Greens of the Month series of posts mentions kale and collards frequently!) Our kale harvests can start October 1, collards Oct 15. If we have planted the right amount, we can harvest each bed once a week in October, November, December, March and April, and once a month in January and February. As the weather starts to warm, production picks up, and we can harvest until the crops bolt at the end of May.

Kale and collard crop requirements

Here in central Virginia, most brassicas are planted in spring and again in fall. Although it can be hard to think about sowing seeds in midsummer, it’s really worthwhile to grow fall brassicas because as they mature in the cooler fall days they develop delicious flavor. Weeds and pests slow down then, too — once established these crops need little care. And will feed you all winter.

The most challenging part of growing fall brassicas is getting the seedlings growing well while the weather is hot. Unlike some cool-weather vegetables such as spinach, brassicas can germinate very well at high temperatures: the ideal is 77°F–85°F (25°C–29°C) for kale, 77°F (25°C) for collards, but up to 95°F (35°C) works. Some people find refrigerating the damp seeds for 24 hours gives a better germination rate. Given enough water, summer seedlings will emerge in only three days. Once they have emerged, the challenge begins. As well as temperature and moisture in the right ranges, the seedlings need light (very plentiful in midsummer!), nutrients, good airflow and protection from pesty bugs. Guarding the plants from bugs is the most challenging for us. We deal organically with flea beetles, harlequin bugs and, sometimes, cabbage worms. Our main defenses are farmscaping and insect netting.

Vates kale in the fall.
Photo Bridget Aleshire

Rotations with fall brassicas

Because fall brassicas are transplanted in summer, it’s possible to grow another vegetable crop, or some good cover crops, earlier in the year. An overwintered cover crop mix of winter rye and crimson clover or hairy vetch could be disked or tilled in at flowering, and be followed by a short-term warm-weather cover such as buckwheat, soy or southern peas. A spring-sown cover crop mix of bell beans (favas), barley and oats does well before all fall brassicas at Roxbury Farm in New York, supplying all the nitrogen the brassicas need. Brassicas are heavy nitrogen feeders. To minimize pests and diseases, we don’t use any brassica cover crops, ever.

Systems for growing collards and kale

Direct sowing, in drills or in “stations” (groups of several seeds sown at the final crop spacing), is straight-forward. We do this with our fall kale. Or try the same systems you use for growing transplants in spring. If you use flats, it can help to have them on benches in an enclosed shade-house, or outdoors, above the 3′ (1 m) height that flea beetles can jump.

Other people do well with flats in June and July, but we avoid it. We use an outdoor nursery seedbed and bare root transplants for collards and most of our fall brassicas, because this suits us best. The nursery bed is near our daily work area, so we’ll pass by and water it. (Our greenhouse is off to one side of our gardens.) We’re always relieved to close the greenhouse transplant season in May, as we no longer need to water little plants many times each day to keep them alive. Having the seedlings directly in the soil drought-proofs them to some extent; they can form deep roots and don’t dry out so fast.

Brassica seedlings under ProtekNet in August.
Photo Pam Dawling

For the seedbeds we use insect netting (ProtekNet) on wire hoops. Rowcover can make the seedlings more likely to die of fungal diseases in hot weather — good airflow is vital. In warm weather, I prefer netting to keep bugs off, because it lets in lots of air.

“No visible brassicas” month

In an attempt to break the relentless lifecycle of the harlequin bugs, we try to have a month from late June to late July with no brassicas visible in our gardens. We make sure to mow down the spring broccoli trunks, the kale and collards, and harvest or pull up any other brassicas. We ensure that our fall brassica seedlings are grown under ProtekNet Pest Control Netting, and we net them as we transplant them. We remove the netting a month after transplanting or sowing.

Timing of kale and collard sowings

The number of days to harvest given in seed catalogs is usually based on spring conditions — plants grow faster in warmer temperatures. We sow collards July 5 and 12. The last date for sowing is about 3 months before the first fall frost date. In our case that means July 20.

Vates kale under ProtekNet. Photo Bridget Aleshire

For kale we use a mixed direct-sow/transplant method that allows for patchy germination, and requires less watering than if direct sowing it all. Three times, (8/4, 8/10, 8/16), we sow two beds with rows 10″ (25 cm) apart and net them. We water them daily until we can see good germination, which is not coincidentally the date for the next sowing.

When the plants have several leaves, we carefully thin them, leaving one plant every foot (30 cm). We use the carefully dug thinnings from those beds to fill gaps and to plant other beds, at the same plant spacing. A reason we like this system is that we want a lot of kale, and there isn’t time to transplant it all.

Planning for kale and collards

In February we make a more detailed plan for the fall brassicas and draw up a spreadsheet of how much of what to sow when.

Kale and collards, our most winter-hardy brassicas, are grown in our raised bed area, which is more accessible for winter harvesting. Each bed is 90′ x 4′ (27.4 x 1.2 m) and fits four rows of most crops, but only three of the bigger collards.

Sowing kale and collards

Our rough formula for all transplanted fall brassicas, such as our collards, is to sow around a foot (30 cm) of seed row for every 12’–15′ (3.6–4.6 m) of crop row, aiming for three seeds per inch (about 1 cm apart). This means sowing 36 seeds for 10 plants grown on 18″ (46 cm) spacing. And we do that twice (72 seeds for 10 plants!), two sowings a week apart, to ensure we have enough plants of the right size. Each week after the first sowing, we weed the previously sown plants, and thin them to one inch (2.5 cm) apart. Then we check the germination, record it and resow to make up the numbers.

Vates kale
Photo Kathryn Simmons

Transplanting collards and kale

We aim to transplant most brassicas at four true leaves (three to four weeks after sowing), but it may slip to five weeks before we get finished. It is better to transplant crops at a younger age in hot weather than you would in spring, because larger plants can wilt from high transpiration losses. If we find ourselves transplanting older plants, we remove a couple of the older leaves to reduce these losses.

We plan to transplant for an hour and a half or two hours in late afternoon or early evening daily, until done. We water the plants ahead of time, and also the soil in the bed if it is dry, because it is very important at this time of year to get adequate water to the plants undergoing the stress of being transplanted. Likewise, good transplanting technique is vital. Water a lot more than you do in spring. If you have drip irrigation, you can more easily give a little water in the middle of each day, which will help cool the roots. With only overhead sprinklers, you may not have the option of watering every day.

For the first few weeks after transplanting, we use wire hoops to support netting to keep the bugs off. Do not float insect netting directly on the plants, as you might do with rowcover: The females are able to land on the netting and lay eggs through the holes. Insects with small mouthparts can bite the leaves through the mesh. Setting out drip tape, watering the soil before planting and setting the plants by an emitter all help survival during the hot summer days.

We plant kale by a mixed direct-sow/transplant method that allows for the possibility of patchy germination, and requires less watering than if we direct sowed it all. We sow two beds on each of three dates, Aug 4, Aug 10 and Aug 16. with 4 rows 10″ (25 cm) apart, and net them. Later we carefully thin them, leaving one plant every foot (30 cm). (We grow Vates, a dwarf variety.) Those plants grow quicker than transplants, as they have no transplant shock. We use the carefully dug thinnings from those beds to fill gaps and to plant more beds, at the same plant spacing. A reason we like this system is that we want a lot of kale, and there isn’t time to transplant it all. Vates kale is the hardiest variety we have found, although I’d love to find a taller Scotch curled variety that could survive our winters (Winterbor does not survive as well as Vates).

Morris Heading Collards. We plant 3 rows in a 4ft wide bed. Photo Kathryn Simmons

Collards are transplanted bare-root, from the nursery bed. We plant two beds of collards, and they have a wide spacing, so there are not many to transplant. We plant at 18″ (46 cm) in the row, with rows a foot (30 cm) apart (three rows per bed).

Caring for fall kale and collard crops

Aftercare for kale and collards is a simple matter of hoeing, weeding, watering as needed and watching for pests.

Two weeks after transplanting the collards  or sowing the kale (late August–early September), we open the netting, hoe or wheelhoe between the rows, and recover the plants. Four weeks after transplanting or sowing, we pack away the netting, hoops and sticks we use to hold down the edges, and cultivate again between the rows and around the plants in the row. For overwintering brassicas grown “on the flat” in the field, we undersow with a clover mix at the second cultivation. You can read about this in my book Sustainable Market Farming.

We do not normally use rowcover in the winter for kale and collards, as they will survive here in Zone 7a without. In harsh winters we lose the collards. Using rowcover would keep crops in better condition later into the winter, and increase the yields, but we have found rowcover fibers stuck in the curly-leaved kale. We don’t like the extra work of dealing with the rowcover, but your situation may warrant it.

Nancy Malone Wheat purple collards with frost. Credit Southern Exposure Seed Exchange

Harvesting kale and collards

Kale and collards are harvested all winter by snapping off the bigger leaves in sustainable amounts. Be careful never to overharvest, or the plants will be stunted and unable to recover to a productive level. For most leafy greens in winter, our mantra is “Leave 8 for Later”, meaning that until you develop an eye for sustainable harvesting, count out from the very center of the plant, being sure not to pick any of the innermost eight leaves. If you can leave one or two more leaves, do so, as more foliage leads to more photosynthesis, which leads to more foliage!

White Russian kale in our hoophouse in February. The Russian kales are not as cold-hardy as Vates. Photo Pam Dawling
Red Russian kale in our hoophouse in February. The red kales d not grow as big as green ones. Photo Pam Dawling.

In January, note if you have grown enough or more than enough for your needs, and plan next year to get closer to just the right amount.

Weeds of the Month for July: Pigweeds (Amaranth species)

 

Redroot pigweed
Photo by: D.G. Swan, WSU CAHNRS and WSU Extension

In May, I wrote about galinsoga, a warm weather annual that dribbles out seeds from an young age. In June, I wrote about docks, tap-rooted perennials that are best tackled early in life. This month is the turn of pigweeds, warm weather annuals that put out seeds in a “Big Bang” as Chuck Mohler describes in Manage Weeds on Your Farm. Pigweeds are fast-growing, tall, erect-to-bushy weeds that respond to high levels of nutrients as found in gardens and crop fields. Like corn, they use the C4 photosynthetic pathway, which means they thrive in high temperatures and high levels of light. They avoid getting shaded by growing fast, and they tolerate drought. Their vulnerability is that they do not produce seeds until they have been growing for some time and have reached a noticeable height.

Green Amaranth/Calaloo, grown for cooking greens.
Photo Baker Creek Seeds

Pigweeds are amaranths, a family that includes valuable food crops used for grains and greens, as well as dreaded weeds such as Palmer Amaranth, Waterhemp and Spiny Amaranth. Pigweeds are frost-tender, but if you have a long enough frost-free period, one plant can produce over 200,000 seeds.

Species of pigweeds

Mark Schonbeck has written a profile of pigweeds on the eOrganic site. He provides a list of eight unwelcomed pigweed species:

Silver Queen sweet corn with wilting pulled pigweed amaranth. Corn is a C4 crop, amarnath (pigweed) a C4 weed. Photo Kathryn Simmons.

Our experience with redroot pigweed in sweet corn

When I first encountered pigweed, I was told they were more-or-less impossible to deal with. Once I learned from Manage Weeds on Your Farm that, as tender annuals, they die with the frost, and as Big Bang weeds, they produce no seeds during most of their growth (unlike galinsoga!), I started a program of pulling them in our sweet corn patches. We used to grow a lot of sweet corn, and this tall crop, taking about ten weeks to mature the harvest, is a good habitat for pigweeds. We cultivate our sweet corn two weeks and four weeks after sowing, then don’t come back until the corn is ripe. This is an excellent window for pigweed to mature in! We started pulling the huge pigweeds each time we harvested corn. Inevitably, the weeds were right next to the corn plants, where our hoeing had failed to dislodge them. We found that if we put one foot against the base of the corn stalk and grasped the pigweed firmly and pulled up, we could usually tug them out. This won’t work if your soil is a tight clay, and if the pigweed breaks, the stem will branch and regrow. Most times, we harvest a patch of corn for two weeks and then disk or till it under. Usually we are turning the crop and weeds under before the regrown pigweed has had a chance to set seed.

Here is a video about Redroot Pigweed:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Muqv3D-EujI

Economic weed thresholds of pigweed

Mark Schonbeck reports:

“Economic thresholds (weed levels that cause a 5% yield loss) for pigweeds emerging with corn and soybean crops have been estimated as low as 0.2–0.5 plants per 10 square feet, and 2–4 plants per 10 square feet for weeds emerging after crop seedlings have several leaves (Costea et al., 2004). In Ontario, redroot pigweed that emerged in corn at the 3–5-leaf stage at populations of 0.5–2.5 weeds per foot of row reduced yields 10–30%, whereas pigweed emerging at the 7-leaf stage had little effect (Knezvic et al., 1994)”

Our experience was that our corn yields were good, and we had found a successful method to manage the levels of pigweed over several years. We were cultivating between the rows and undersowing with soy at 4 weeks after sowing the corn, so the pigweeds growing were only those very close to the corn stalks. I do picture that an understory of pigweed would have a serious effect.

Spiny Amaranth

Spiny amaranth – a weed to exterminate by careful pulling.
Photo Pam Dawling

Spiny amaranth has been designated the world’s 15th worst agricultural weed. We have twice eliminated spiny amaranth from our gardens for a number of years, and then had it return. The seeds can remain viable in the soil and regrow when they are exposed to light. Although not as tall-growing as redroot pigweed, spiny amaranth has other ways of succeeding against those who would remove it from their crops: The nasty 0.5” (13 mm) spines (borne in opposing pairs at each leaf node) are not very visible among the branches, and are close enough together to make grasping the stem difficult.

The leaves of spiny amaranth are a darker green than redroot pigweed and have a V-shaped mark in a different color. Spiny amaranths can produce even more seeds than redroot pigweed: 235,000 each. Beware importing animal manure from other farms, and even gravel. I have seen a spiny amaranth germinate in a fairly large gravel pile brought in for road repairs.

Six methods of tackling pigweeds

Mark Schonbeck lists six methods of tackling pigweeds in organic production systems, and recommends using a combination of:

  • Cultivation, flame weeding, and manual removal 2-3 weeks after emergence
  • Stale seedbed
  • Mulching
  • Crop rotations that vary timing of tillage and other operations [our sweet corn was one year in 3 or4]
  • Cover crops and competitive cash crops
  • Measures to prevent or minimize production of viable seeds

Pigweed Flea Beetle

Disonycha glabrata – Pigweed Flea Beetle.
Photo from Bug Guide.net

Pigweeds even have their own striped flea beetle, Disonycha glabrata from the Chrysomelidae family. It is a large flea beetle. More the size of a striped cucumber beetle, but with a reddish thorax. It feeds on Redroot Pigweed (Amaranthus retroflexus) and other amaranths, so we never even try to grow salad amaranths as the leaves get riddles with holes. The first larval stage lasts 3.6 days, the second 2.6 days, and the third 2.9 days.  It spends 13.5 days in the soil.

Another Weed Management Resource

The book Steel in the Field, available as a downloadable pdf from SARE

Steel in the Field: A Farmer’s Guide to Weed-Management Tools. 1997. Edited by Greg Bowman. Sustainable Agriculture Research and Education (SARE). This book is a farmer’s guide to weed management tools using cultivation equipment.

Success with Growing Cabbage in Spring

Young Early Jersey Wakefield cabbage, a fast maturing pointed variety.
Photo Pam Dawling

Some of this material is from my book Sustainable Market Farming.

Cabbages can be reliable workhorses, providing large harvests over long periods. In colder regions, cabbages are planted only in the spring and grow all summer, into the fall and winter, until cold weather kills them. In the South, they are a spring/early summer and a fall/overwintered crop, as it’s too hot to grow them in the summer. In parts of California and the Pacific Northwest, they’ll grow year-round.

Cabbage crop requirements

Cabbages do best on fertile, well-drained soil with adequate moisture. They require a lot of potassium, so a sprinkling of wood ash, kelp meal or granite dust could be helpful. Calcium, boron, iron, manganese and molybdenum are also important for good brassica crops — healthy, biologically active soils can usually supply enough of all these. If not, amend as needed.

Young Farao cabbage, a good fast-growing round variety.
Photo Pam Dawling

Cabbage varieties

Be clear about what kind of cabbage you are looking for, especially whether it’s for fresh eating, slaw, sauerkraut or storage, and what size you want and how many days from seeding to harvest.

  • For quick-maturing cabbage, we choose Early Jersey Wakefield (63d OP), Golden Acre (62d OP) and Farao (64d F1) (All days to maturity in this list are from transplanting in spring. Add 14 days for direct sowing. Subtract 10-14 days for warm weather sowings.)
  • For large solid cabbage for making sauerkraut, we choose Gunma (110d F1), Tribute (103d F1) or Early Flat Dutch (85d OP)
  • For a green cabbage that holds well in hot weather, to extend the season as long as possible, the flat Tendersweet (71d F1) is tasty and works well for us. It is good for coleslaw and wraps, but not for storage
  • We like a red that’s fairly large and yet quick-maturing (many reds are too slow for us, taking us deep into hot weather). We used to favor Super Red 80 (73d), but gave it up after two poor years. Ruby Perfection (85d F1) stores fairly well, as does Integro (85d F1)
  • We like savoy cabbage, and find Melissa (85d F1) and Famosa (80d F1) quick and reliable
  • For storage we have liked Storage #4 (95d F1), Kaitlyn (94d F1), and Late Flat Dutch (100d OP)
  • Deadon (105d F1) is a particularly cold-hardy one to grow into the winter. It survives down to at least 10°F (-12°C)
  • High Mowing and Johnny’s Seeds have good selections of over twenty cabbage varieties, including the 77d 10-17 lb (4.5-7.7 k) Megaton, good for fresh eating and kraut.

Sowing cabbage seed

A seed flat of cabbage and several flats of spotted out seedlings in our greenhouse in February.
Photo Pam Dawling

In early spring, transplants have the advantage over direct-seeded crops — they grow faster under protected conditions and bring earlier harvests. At other times of year, you may prefer to direct seed.

Work back from your desired harvest date to calculate the sowing date. Naturally you’ll need to allow for your climate and choose a realistic transplanting date. We start our very first cabbages in our greenhouse in mid–late January, as soon as I’m mentally prepared to start a whole new year. Maincrop cabbage follows in mid-February.

Despite being a cool-weather crop, brassicas actually germinate very well at high temperatures: the ideal is 77°F–85°F (25°C–30°C), and 95°F (35°C) is still OK. Given enough water, the seedlings will emerge in four and a half days at the low end of this range, and at the top in only three days. The minimum temperature for good germination is 40°F (4.5°C), but you’ll need to wait more than two weeks for emergence if it’s that chilly.

We start our spring cabbages in home-made open wood flats, sowing 3–4 seeds per inch (5–10 mm apart). We press a plastic ruler 0.25″ (6 mm) deep into the seed compost to make a small furrow, spacing the rows 2″–3″ (5 cm) apart.

Once they have emerged, the seedlings need good light, nutrients, airflow and protection from bugs. 60°F–70°F (15°C–21°C) is a good temperature range for growing them. As soon as the seed leaves are fully open, we spot (prick) them out to 4″ (10 cm) deep flats, with 40 plants per 12″ x 24″ (30 x 60 cm) flat. The plants grow to transplanting size in these flats.

Spotting cabbage seedlings from a seed flat into a transplant flat.
Photo Wren Vile

For the last two weeks before transplanting, harden off the plants by moving them into cooler, breezier, brighter conditions.

Transplanting cabbage

We grow spring cabbage in 4′ (1.2 m) beds, at two rows per bed, with plants 18″ (50 cm) apart. Mini-cabbages can be spaced at 8″–12″ (20–30 cm) in the row, with rows 12″–18″ (30–45 cm) apart, and may give higher total yields as well as heads of a more useful size.

We aim to transplant at four true leaves (5–8 weeks after sowing in spring). This is early to mid-March for the earliest cabbage (seven weeks old), very early April for maincrop cabbage. Soil temperatures of 65°F–75°F (18°C–24°C) are ideal. Optimal air temperatures for most brassicas are 60°F–65°F (15°C–18°C).

Water the seedlings well before transplanting, and plant all the way up to the base of the first true leaves to give the stem good support. Press the soil very firmly around the plants so the roots have good soil contact and won’t die in an air pocket. I was taught to tug on a leaf after transplanting: if well planted the leaf will tear and the plant will remain in the ground. Water within half an hour of planting and again on the third and seventh days, and then once a week.

Young spring cabbage with a hay mulch. Wren VIle

For cabbage, the sixth and seventh leaf stage is the most vulnerable. If the weather deteriorates at this critical time, give your plants extra protection. High daytime temperatures can to some extent compensate for low nighttime temperatures — it’s cold days and cold nights together that do the damage. We use thick rowcover over our spring cabbages for a few weeks after transplanting, then may switch to insect netting.

Two weeks after transplanting, we check the plants and fill the gaps with transplants we have kept for this. If it is necessary to use big plants to fill gaps, we pinch off a few of the lower leaves to reduce their water needs.

Caring for  cabbage in spring and summer

About a month after transplanting maincrop cabbage (mid-May), we remove the rowcovers and the sticks we use to hold them down.

We use only overhead sprinkler irrigation (not drip tape) for spring cabbage, which helps cool the leaves and can wash off aphids. Organic mulches help keep the soil cool, as well as adding lots of organic matter to the soil. Brassica roots are relatively shallow, so long droughty spells without irrigation can cause problems. One inch (2.5 cm) of water per week is about right.

One of our impact sprinkler tripods, in a broccoli and cabbage patch.
Photo Pam Dawling

Cabbage pest control

Using rowcovers or insect netting keeps many pests off the plants while they are small. We have not had much trouble with aphids, perhaps partly because of our overhead sprinklers; insecticidal soap sprayed three times, once every five days, can usually deal with them. Our worst pest is the harlequin bug. When necessary, we handpick them. Ladybugs are reputed to eat harlequin bug eggs.

Sometimes we have had enough cabbage worms to make Bt (Bacillus thuringiensis) necessary, but usually paper wasps eat the caterpillars. The action threshold is an average of 1 cabbage looper, 1.5 imported cabbageworms, 3.3 armyworms or 5 diamondback moth larvae per 10 plants. Below this level you can do watchful waiting rather than spraying with Bt or spinosad. Apparently paper or plastic fake cabbage moths on sticks will deter more from moving in. There are templates for homemade cabbage moth decoys online. The eyespots are important!

Yarrow flowering in our hoophouse in late November, 13 months after sowing.
Photo Pam Dawling

We are also lucky enough to have the naturally occurring wasp parasite of cabbage worms, the Braconid wasp Cotesia species, which are found as small cottony white or yellowish oval cocoons in groups on brassica leaves. The Cotesia wasps like umbelliferous flowers, and overwinter on yarrow as well as brassicas. If you find Cotesia cocoons and your brassicas aren’t diseased, you can leave plants in the field over winter. Or you could collect up leaves with cocoons in late fall and store them at 32°F–34°F (0°C–1°C) until spring. Hopefully no one will clean out your fridge without asking.

To float out worms and aphids after harvest, soak the produce in warm water with a little vinegar for up to fifteen minutes, then rinse.

Harvesting cabbage

Our cabbage heads up from May 25 and some hold till July 15. For storage cabbage (a valuable crop in summers in warm climates with scarce fresh leafy greens), we set the cut heads upside down on the stump, in the “basket” of outer leaves, and come back an hour later to gather them into net bags. This allows the cut stem to dry out and seal over, improving storability.

Mature Farao early cabbage. Note the curling-back leaf on the head, a sign of maturity.
Photo Pam Dawling

Vegetable Seed Varieties for 2024

 

Preparing to sow Rainbow Chard in 2018.
Photo Pam Dawling

Vegetable Seed Varieties for 2024

Have you ordered your seeds for next year yet? The earlier you order, the best chance you have of getting the varieties you want. Later, some will sell out. It’s true that when you order very early, some seeds won’t be available yet. The seed growers are still drying and cleaning them, weighing them and running them through germination testing. Your patience will be rewarded with high quality seeds.

I love looking through catalogs to find new exciting-sounding varieties! After so many years of gardening, I’ve tried lots of different kinds, and have definitely grown attached to some reliable favorites. I recommend planting a small amount of a variety new to you that sounds good, alongside your usual well-loved variety. And what do I mean by “sounds good”?

In 2014 I wrote Reading Between the Lines in the Seed Catalogs to share what I’d learned about decoding catalog-speak, and not getting distracted by wondrous claims, failing to notice the catalog never even claimed it had good flavor. Or high yields. Or good disease-resistance. That post lists 15 features to look for.

We look for flavor, productivity, disease-resistance, an appropriate fit with our climate or latitude, general adaptability, varieties that don’t require erecting elaborate trellises, ones that don’t sprawl too widely, ones that don’t take a really long time to reach maturity.

If we’ve had a few years of poor performance from a crop, we’ll try several new varieties. We have done trials of heat-tolerant eggplants, winter spinach for the hoophouse and outdoors, storage cabbage, and now we need to start over with broccoli.

Green Magic broccoli Credit Johnnys Seeds

For many years we grew three varieties of hybrid broccoli with different number of days to maturity. That enabled us to sow them all on the same day, transplant them all on the same day (or in the same week), and get an extended harvest period. Some of our favorites dropped out of the market, we floundered with various kinds, including some Open Pollinated varieties that sounded good. This year I am advocating for Green Magic (57d F1, 6-8″ main head and sideshoots too); Belstar (65d F1, also 6-8″ main head, plus sideshoots); and Marathon (68d F1) or Fiesta (70d F1, 6-7″ head, few sideshoots, short harvest window). Marathon has done well for us in the past. In my experience, broccoli is a crop where hybrids are much more productive than OP types.

Green Machine zucchini. Photo Johnny’s Selected Seeds

Our much-loved Tendergrey zucchini, one of the flecked pale green types, isn’t easily available this year. But Green Machine (45d F1) sounds very good! Open plant habit is a phrase I like. Moderate spines is one I don’t like, but we have some pull-on plastic sleeves to deal with irritating plants. Widely adapted, excellent disease package, and high yields all appeal to me.

We rely on Provider (50d OP) and Bush Blue Lake snap beans every year, with a short row of Strike in the hoophouse a month earlier than outdoors. We found we need an upright variety to get nice beans undercover, as the bean plants grow sprawlier than they do outside, and we don’t want to be treading on them.

Washing Cylindra beets for storage.
Photo Wren Vile

We rely on Cylindra or Formanova (54d OP) beets, long-shaped tender ones that grow up out of the ground, are tender and easy to peel after cooking. Seems like the yield must be high when half the root is above ground, and half below!

Premium Late Dutch cabbage (100d OP) has done well for us. Johnny’s has a lovely-sounding storage cabbage, Promise (96d F1). 6 ½ lbs at 18″ spacing, 9-10 lbs at 24″ spacing. And two attractive purplish Chinese cabbages Red Trumpet (60d F1), a tall Michihili type, and Merlot (60d F1), said to be an improved Red Dragon Napa type. I hadn’t got round to trying Red Dragon yet, so I can’t speak to its shortcomings. Merlot admits to being more prone to tipburn than green varieties and to be somewhat susceptible to bolting. Some trials on a small-scale are called for!

Merlot purple Chinese cabbage.
Photo Johnny’s Selected Seeds

Carrots – oh why so many yellow, purple, red and black ones? None in my experience match the succulence and growth rate of orange Danvers 126.

Collards – for years I have loved Morris Heading, but the recent explosion of options brought us by the Heirloom Collard Project is leading us to try others. Some have remarkable colors, combined with high yields.

The delicious early Bodacious sweet corn is harder to find. Thanks Southern Exposure for carrying it. Our reliable favorite Kandy Korn has become hard to find.

Our favorite slicing cucumber has been renamed by Fedco as Generally, a name we’ve been using for years. This year we also tried South Wind from Common Wealth Seed Growers and were quite taken with its sweetness.

South Wind slicing cucumber.
Photo Common Wealth Seed Growers

As always, there are new frilly mustards for baby greens and salad mixes. We like Mizuna, Golden Frills, Scarlet Frills and especially Ruby Streaks. I feel drawn towards purple stemmed Ember and dark red Miz America.

For leeks, we grow King Richard and Lincoln for fall and Tadorna for overwintering in our Zone 7a climate. No complaints there. all are very good for their purpose.

I’m always on the lookout for new lettuces. This summer we tried Albachiara from High Mowing, and it did very well. We’ll get more for this coming year. It’s a Batavian heat-tolerant type. Now our climate is changing, we need to grow Batavians for more weeks of heat. Finding a new one is great! Dark red Cherokee has been my favorite.

I shouldn’t even look at the spring lettuce selection, or I’ll order more than we can use in the short spring season we have. Most spring varieties can be grown in the fall here too, but we like to switch to cold-tolerant ones.

Ezrilla, a favourite cold-hardy lettuce.
Photo Wren Vile

This winter we are growing the beautiful Rhone in our hoophouse bed of cut-and-come again leaf varieties, along with Ezrilla, Hampton, Brentwood, Tango, Revolution, Oscarde and Panisse.

For scallions we like Evergreen Hardy White (65d OP) every time, and feel no need to try another.

We have been growing Sugar Ann early dwarf snap peas in our hoophouse (sown Feb 1), but next year we are trying Oregon Giant snow peas instead. We think snap peas are best raw, and used to cut them into our salad mixes. But over the past few years, by the time the snap peas are ready to harvest, our winter salad mix days are coming to a close, and our outdoor lettuce head harvest is starting. We don’t grow enough snap peas to serve them on their own in big bowlfuls. We think we’ll be able to pick enough snow peas for stirfry mixes instead! In March we sow Sugar Ann outdoors and get plenty.

For sweet peppers our keywords are prolific, thick-walled, tasty, and 90 days or less from transplant to ripe harvest (76d to green). We like fairly large peppers too, and avoid small pointy ones that could get confused with hot peppers in the fridge.

Tomatoes are a whole topic on their own. We love Sun Gold and Black Cherry, Mountain Magic and Garden Peach. Others come and go. Next year we are trying Damsel  (73d F1). Damsel is in the new tomato category called “Hylooms” – hybrids resembling heirlooms in color and flavor, with added disease resistance.

Damsel (71d F1) Hyloom tomato.
Photo High Mowing Seeds

Success with Spinach for Fall, Winter and Spring

January spinach from our second hoophouse sowing.
Photo Pam Dawling

Success with Spinach for Fall, Winter and Spring

Spinach is a much-loved crop for us. We sow outdoors and in the hoophouse in early September for harvesting from fall through to spring (April). We sow outdoors in late September for a crop to overwinter as small plants and be harvested in the spring. We also sow in our coldframes in mid-September. These are more sheltered than the beds outdoors, and the spinach makes faster growth. We sow more spinach in the hoophouse in October and November. We sow in the hoophouse in January to transplant outdoors and in the hoophouse in February for spring harvests. We are able to keep harvesting spinach (leaves, not whole plants) from October 15 to May 25, all the way through the winter. Central Virginia is too hot to have spinach during the summer (we switch to chard).

Spinach over-wintered in our cold frame
Photo wren Vile

Unsurprisingly, I have written about spinach several times.

Spinach Variety Trials Conclusion in May 2019. Our top general favorite is Acadia, although Reflect does better outdoors overwinter. This post includes links to earlier posts about spinach varieties, including Spinach Trials Update, April 2018.

What causes spinach leaves to turn yellow, in May 2019

yellowed spinach in May. We had transplanted too soon after tilling under some big weeds.
Photo Pam Dawling
A bed of healthy green Reflect spinach on May 3
Photo Pam Dawling

What makes vegetable crops bolt and how can I stop it? March 2021

Spinach Varieties

Choose varieties that do well in climates similar to yours, in the conditions you have when you plant and harvest. We used to grow Tyee for all plantings, and were very happy with it. But it has been pulled from the market because it had disease problems in the Pacific North West, where spinach seed is grown. We have tried and not continued Chevelle, Corvair, Renegade (grows fast, but has thin leaves and bolts early in spring), Avon (Downy Mildew in winter).

Also see the 2015 Greenbank Farm Spinach Variety Trial. The farm is in Washington State. They evaluated 10 varieties of savoyed and semi-­‐savoyed spinach with two side-­‐by-­‐side replication in spring. Abundant Bloomsdale, Bloomsdale Long Standing, Butterflay, Giant Winter, Dolce Vita, Longstanding Bloomsdale, Lyra, Solstizio, Tyee, Winter Bloomsdale. The overall star of their trial was Solstizio from Nash’s Organic Produce.

Spinach plants on February 5. left to right: Avon, Renegade, Escalade, Acadia.
Photo Pam Dawling

Paul and Sandy Arnold in Argyle, New York, made a great slide show reviewing Spinach Varieties in High Tunnels.  I think it’s no longer available online, but I did learn that in 2019, their top Winter Spinach Varieties were Escalade, Carmel, Whale, Space, Reflect; top Summer Spinach Varieties: Banjo, Seaside, Woodpecker.

In 2011-2012, High Mowing Seeds in northern Vermont did a spinach variety trial with 24 varieties. Three farmers in Iowa conducted a 2021 trial of spinach varieties and seedling methods. They compared yield, bolting and yellowing among three spinach seeding methods: seeder (1x rate), seeder (2x rate), hand-seed (2x rate); and between two varieties (Kolibri, Kookaburra). Two of them found no statistically significant difference of seeding method on yield; one found no difference in yields between the two varieties, but using a seeder at a double rate produced significantly higher yields than the other two methods.

When to sow fall spinach

Spinach does not germinate in hot soil! Use a soil thermometer and wait for the soil to cool to 68F (20C), or see the next section about sprouting spinach seed in a cold place. If you have no soil thermometer, see my post chickweed, hen-bit and dead-nettle, and use the info that was originally written with lettuce in mind, for spinach! There are photos there of these three plants at seedling stage. These are winter annual weeds here, that don’t grow in summer. Once we see their seedlings emerging in late August (a cool summer year like 2023) or September (most years) we know the soil has cooled enough to sow lettuce and spinach directly in the ground.

A trick for getting good timely germination of spinach seed is to put it (in sturdy resealable plastic bags or jars) in the freezer for about two weeks. Take the seeds out of the freezer the day before you want to sow (or start sprouting them), but – important – do not open the bag or jar. Leave it to warm to ambient temperature before opening. Otherwise the warm humid air will rush in and coat the cold seeds with condensation, reducing the shelf life of whatever seed you have left over for another time.

See our Spinach Variety Trials and Planting Plan, in February 2018:

  • September 6 is our first sowing (sprouted seeds) in the hoophouse for winter harvest 10/30-2/15, or later if it doesn’t bolt.
  • We sow outdoors on September 7 (sprouted seeds) for growing under rowcover and harvesting in fall and winter.
  • September 18-20 we sow in our coldframes and outdoors for harvest in early spring, until late May.
  • October 24 we make our second hoophouse sowing, to feed us November 25 to May 7.
  • On November 9,we make a third hoophouse sowing, intending to use these plants to fill gaps in our hoophouse as other winter crops come to an end.
  • January 16 we make more sowings in the hoophouse, some to continue to fill gaps there along the edges of the beds where they won’t fight with the tomatoes and so on, which we transplant starting March 15. Most of the spinach sown on this date is for transplanting outdoors on February 21.
  • January 29 we sow in flats in the greenhouse if we see we haven’t got enough bare-root transplants in the hoophouse.
  • February 10 If we don’t have enough transplants, then on this date we sow outdoors with rowcover, for spring harvests until May 25 if we’re lucky. We have backup plans on backup plans for this!
  • In the hoophouse we continue transplanting spinach to fill gaps until March 31.

 

Sprouting seeds before sowing is a way to success in hot or very cold weather.
Photo Pam Dawling

Sprouting Spinach Seed

This very easy work-around involves soaking the spinach seed in water overnight, draining it, and putting the jar on its side in the fridge for a week. If you remember, give the jar a quarter-turn each day to even out the moisture. You are not growing bean sprouts! A little neglect will not cause harm. The ideal is to have short sprouts, not long ones, as those break off more easily.  Sow the seed in the furrows gently, by hand. If the sprouts have got tangled, add some water to float them apart, drain them, spread them on a tray, or a layer of rowcover, to dry a bit, then mix with some inert dry soil-friendly material like uncooked corn grits or bran, which will help them not stick together.

Sowing Spinach in Speedling Flats and Floating them in Water

Another option is to start the spinach in flats and transplant it all. That’s a lot of work, but we found we could save on the daily attention time and the transplant time by using 120-cell Styrofoam Speedling flats. Sow one or two seeds per cell, then float the flats all day in water. Depending on your scale, this could be a baby bath or a stock tank. Remove the flats each evening and let them drain all night (while it is hopefully cooler). With just twice a day visits and no hand-watering, this is a big time saver, and we have got good germination rates.

Transplanting spinach from a Speedling flat. Butter knives are the tool of choice for easing the little wedges out of the tapered cells.
Photo Denny Ray McElya

When it comes time to transplant, the tool of choice is a butter knife. Use the knife to wiggle a wedge-shaped hole in the bed. Slide the knife down the sloping side of the cell, and, holding the base of the plant with one hand, use the knife hand to lift and flick the plug out. If all goes well, the plug will be then be resting on the now-horizontal knife, and you can slide it into the pre-made hole and firm it in.

Growing Spinach

Spinach makes growth whenever the air temperature is 40F (4.4C) or more. So any winter protection you can provide, in the way of cozy microclimates, rowcover, coldframes, or a hoophouse, will increase your yield. Spinach is more cold-hardy than many people realize. It dies at 0°F (-18°C) unprotected outdoors. Savoyed varieties tend to be a little hardier than smooth-leaved types. Large-leaved savoyed spinach outdoors with no protection can get seriously damaged at 10F (-12C). Small-leaved plants are OK down to 5F (-15C).

Weeding rowcovered spinach in winter.
Photo Wren Vile

Our outdoor spinach gets hoops and thick rowcover (Typar, 1.25 oz/sq yd spunbonded polypropylene, with 75% light transmission, and about 6 F (3.3 C) degrees of frost protection). It can last for 6 years or more. When we got 0F (-18C) the spinach leaves that touched the rowcover got big patches of beige/tan dead cells, but the plants recovered to produce more leaves.

Ben Hartman (author of The Lean Farm) wrote Testing the Limits of Cold Tolerance in Growing for Market magazine in February 2014. He reported that his young hoophouse spinach in Goshen, Indiana, with mid-weight rowcover survived -16F (XXX). Ben points out that spinach less than 1″ (2.5 cm) tall is very cold-tolerant. Bigger plants need more protection if it’s going to get that cold.

 You can read more about growing spinach in my Cooking Greens monthly series.

Growing bare root spinach transplants

Small spinach seedlings for bare root transplants. Photo Pam Dawling

We grow our spring spinach transplants (as well as kale and collards) in the soil in our hoophouse, sowing them in late January. See bare root transplants . You can find more links and info in that post. Growing bare root transplants saves a lot of work and a lot of greenhouse space.

Harvesting Spinach

Our goal is sustainable long-season harvesting. This is important for winter crops, as making a new sowing during cold dark days will not produce much food until spring comes around. It’s like the goose that lays the golden eggs – keep the leafy “golden eggs” coming

We harvest spinach by cutting individual leaves and leaving the plant to continue to produce more.

Our rule is “Leave 8 for later” – cut off large outer leaves close to the base of the plant, being sure to keep at least 8 of the inner leaves growing on each plant. Over-harvesting leads to decline.

When we finally pull up the bolting plants in spring, I’m always amazed to see how many leaf-scars there are on each plant, showing just how much we’ve harvested.

Hoophouse spinach. Far row: bolting Renegade; Near row: Escalade.
Photo Pam Dawling

For those relatively new to this blog but living in a similar climate zone, I want to point you to The Complete Twin Oaks Garden Task List Month-by-Month. It includes a link for each month’s task list. I notice from the site stats that some of you are finding your way there, but now there are so many years’ worth of posts it’s perhaps harder to find. Happy browsing!

Year-Round Hoophouse Vegetables slideshow, VABF Handouts

Tatsoi in the mist, November.
Photo Wren Vile

Busy Conference Season is here!

I just got back from the Virginia Association for Biological Farming conference in Roanoke. There I gave a half-day presentation on Year-Round Hoophouse Vegetables, which you can watch here:

The conference was very well-attended, and not everyone at my workshop on Friday, or the Alliums Year-Round 90 minute workshop on Sunday morning got a handout. I promised to post them here, and now I’m making good. I’m also posting the handout for the third workshop I gave, Asian Greens in the Winter Hoophouse. This rounds out the set, and gives a chance to those who went to a different workshop at that time to get a look in.

This coming weekend I will be venturing north to NOFA-Mass and giving a presentation on Crop Planning for Sustainable Vegetable Production.

To those who are wondering what happened to my monthly post Fruit for the Month, I postponed it. There isn’t so much fruit in January, is there?

How cold can leafy greens and salad crops survive?

Our hoophouse beds after the nights at 2F (-17C) and 8F (-13C). Looking amazing! Pam Dawling

We were luckier with the weather than many people over the weekend (12/23-12/26/2022). And so were our vegetable crops. On Friday 12/23 we prepared for a suddenly very cold night. It was very windy as we battled to stop the hoophouse windows from blowing open. We finally got some shims, a hammer and a stepladder, and wedged them closed. They stayed that way until Tuesday 12/27. We were fortunate in getting no precipitation (I hate ice!) and no power outage.

Pool noodles repurposed as draft excluders.
Pam Dawling

We fortified the doors with our rock collecting buckets, and prevented most of the under-door drafts with our pool noodle draft excluders. They have a rope running through them, which is hooked onto small cup-hooks on the door frame. We repurposed noodles that had been used as props at a party or some other kind of event. They had been covered in tube socks and had glued-on googly eyes.

Rolls of rowcover at the ready in our hoophouse.
Pam Dawling

It was a bit unnerving being in the hoophouse as it creaked and groaned in the wind. In the winter we keep rolls of rowcover ready for any night we think will be below 8F (-13C). We unrolled the rowcovers by lunchtime and laid tools on the ends nearest the doors. I was worried that if we lost power, and therefore the inflation, it would get very cold indeed in the hoophouse.

The DIY manometer in our hoophouse. (the background lines have faded). Pam Dawling

Since we last changed the plastic we haven’t managed to get the recommended 1/3” (8.5mm) pressure difference in the “bubble” between the plastic layers, compared to our normal air pressure. Mostly we don’t even get ¼” (6.5mm). The “bubble” provides thermal insulation as well as physical strength against snow or ice buildup, and strong winds.

It got down to 2F (-17C) outdoors Friday night, and Saturday didn’t warm up much. I don’t actually know what the night temperature was in the hoophouse as our recorded low temperatures don’t make sense: 14F (-10C) for four consecutive nights (Fri to Mon). I suspect we didn’t reset the thermometer correctly. Usually the hoophouse can hold 8 F (4.5 C) degrees warmer than outdoors, but not 12 F (7 C). It looks like it did, perhaps because we didn’t open it all day!

Soil thermometer in our hoophouse on 27 December 2022.
Pam Dawling

The soil is still nice and warm in there: 59F (15C). That really helps. The rowcovers are usually removed in the daytime, either pulled aside if we expect to need them again the next night, or rolled up out of the way. Most of the time they stay rolled up at the east end of the hoophouse. We appreciate not needing to deal with rowcovers most of the time! On Saturday 24th, the temperature maximum for the day outdoors was 24F (-4.5C), and we kept the rowcovers in place over the crops. On Sunday the high outdoors was 28F (-2C) so we pulled the rowcovers aside until the night. On Monday 26th the night-time forecast was benign enough that we rolled the rowcovers up. And now we get a milder spell.

Hakurei turnips with frozen yellow leaves where they touched the plastic (rowcover protected the plants). Pam Dawling

How did the crops fare? It’s not always obvious at first if a crop has been killed by cold or not, But I can now say with confidence that nothing died. The edge beds are always the coldest. The south edge bed had Hakurei turnips, delicious and notoriously the least cold-hardy turnip variety. Most of the globe of the turnip sits on the surface of the soil. You can see in the photo that some of the leaves, the ones right by the wall plastic, have been killed and turned yellow. But the roots themselves (with rowcover over them) seem fine.

Bright Lights chard with cold-damaged stems in our hoophouse north edge bed after nights at 2F and 8F
Pam Dawling

Over the other side, in the north bed, we have some Bright Lights chard, among other things. Multi-colored chards are less cold-hardy than red ones, which in turn are less cold-hardy than green ones. We know we take a risk in growing Bright Lights through the winter, but we so enjoy the sight of the short pieces of colored stems in our salad mixes that we take the risk. Some of the stems have curled over, probably on their way to dying, but the plants live on, to provide many more salads this winter! And some cooked greens too.

Some of the giant senposai leaves, where not fully protected by the relatively narrow rowcover, have developed tan dead spots, so those leaves can just continue as the plants’ solar panels until we get tired of looking at them and decide they are no longer needed.

Each winter I update my Winter-Kill Temperatures of Cold-Hardy Vegetables list, except this past spring I had nothing new to add. Outdoors, I noticed today that the tatsoi has definitely died, the Vates kale and the spinach have survived (uncovered) and the small garlic leaves don’t seem troubled. The leftover lettuce transplants have been damaged, if not killed.