Soil Test Results: Hoophouse Soil pH

Five Star Grape tomato in our hoophouse. Photo Alexis Yamashita

Soil Test Results: Hoophouse Soil pH

Last week I promised to say more about soil tests, pH and what we are doing to improve our hoophouse soil.

The pH is a measure of how acidic or alkaline (basic) a solution is, assessed on a scale from 0 to 14. It is based on the concentration of hydrogen ions. Think of the “p” as standing for Potential, and the “H” as standing for Hydrogen ions. The lower the number, the higher the concentration of H ions (less Potential left!) and the more acidic. Pure water is neutral (neither acidic nor alkaline), at the midpoint of the pH scale, with pH rated as 7.0. Substances with a pH less than 7 are acidic; those with a pH greater than 7 are alkaline.

Battery acid has a pH of 0; lemons measure about 2, and milk measures between 6 and 7. To dig deeper it is important to understand that the pH scale is a logarithmic scale, meaning that each whole number change in pH represents a tenfold increase or decrease in acidity or alkalinity. A solution with a pH of 4 is ten times more acidic than one with a pH of 5. A pH of 3 is 100 times more acidic than a pH of 5 (10 x 10).

Image from epa.gov

A good place to start learning more about soil testing is

Conventional Chemical Soil Testing in Organic Farming Systems

There you can find an explanation about the value of soil testing and info on choosing a soil testing lab. The one nutrient that is often not assessed is nitrogen, which combines readily within the soil with other materials, making it difficult to measure and interpret results. See Soil Microbial Nitrogen Cycling for Organic Farms for more information.

For information on converting conventional fertilizer recommendations to ones for organic growing, see How to Convert an Inorganic Fertilizer Recommendation to an Organic One from the University of Georgia Extension.

Interpreting Soil Test Buffer pH Reports from Commercial Labs. (Alabama)

Lime recommendations made by soil testing labs use two different soil tests: soil pH and buffer pH. Buffer pH measures the soil’s resistance to changes in pH, which affects how much lime is required to increase soil pH to a target pH (or sulfur to lower it). Soils high in OM and clay need more lime to raise pH than sandy, low OM soils do. For example, a sandy soil with pH 5.0 may need 1 ton of ground limestone to raise the pH to 6.5, while a clay soil with the same pH may need 4 tons. Each soil testing lab has its own buffer solution and tables or formulas used for calculating amendment requirements.

Our hoophouse beds after the nights at 2F (-17C) and 8F (-13C). Looking amazing!
Pam Dawling

Soil Test Recommendations for Virginia

Virginia Tech recommends writing in a crop code number on the form you send in with your sample, even if you will be growing a mix of vegetables next year. This enables them to give a recommendation, which you can modify as needed. You could choose the crop which will occupy the most space in the area, or a representative of the main crop family. For example, for brassicas, choose Cabbage. Their document linked in the title gives the numerical equivalents of the L- to VH ratings for P, K, Ca, Mg results, and soil test calibrations related to soil pH for Zn and Mn. There is also a list of Critical Soil Test Levels for various factors, giving you a heads-up when action is needed to remedy a problem. Also included are fertilizer recommendations for NPK. You will need to get the equivalent information from your local extension office or the organization that did your soil tests, as testing procedures vary.

Dealing with Alkaline Hoophouse Soil

Outdoors, we more often need to make the soil less acidic, so we add lime. Adding sulfur to the soil can make soil more acidic (bring down the pH). This is commonly done before growing blueberries for example.

Blueberry bush with buds in March. Photo Pam Dawling

The Clemson Soil Acidification Calculator lets you enter your data and learn how much sulfur to add. (And if you need a lime calculator instead, to reduce the acidity of your soil, they have a calculator for that too.) Sulfur additions can take many months to show results. For example, to reduce the pH of loamy soil from 7.2 to 6.5, the calculator informs me I would need to add 12.6lbs/1000ft2 of elemental sulfur, and that this is too much to add all at once, so would be best divided into at least two applications with a gap of 2-3 months between applications. They further recommend re-checking the pH before subsequent applications. They recommend only applying S when temperatures are cool (<75°F), and to water in immediately after application.

Elemental Sulfur from Seven Springs Farm Supply, Floyd, VA

Water-soluble products can be a way to bring down the soil pH in hoophouses.

Hoophouse soils can drift towards alkaline over time (partly due to the pH of the irrigation water) and need a little acidification. The pelleted elemental sulfur used outdoors is unsuitable for use in covered spaces that have drip irrigation, as the pellets will not readily break apart.

Magnesium Sulfate (Epsom salts) from Seven Springs Farm Supply, Floyd, VA

Aluminum sulfate (28.1% S) could be used in the above example at 84lbs/1000ft2 dissolved in water. But it can damage plants and is not OMRI listed. Instead, use OMRI listed Epsom salts (magnesium sulfate), which is 12.9% S. Consider that this practice may actually lead to more problems, as the acids used to bring the pH down can add additional salts to the soil, in this case aluminum or magnesium.

Your irrigation water should have a pH of between 5 and 7. Once you know the pH, determine the amount of acid you’ll need to add to neutralize it. For more about fertigation (fertilizer-irrigation), see https://extension.umn.edu/nutrient-management-specialty-crops/soil-health-and-nutrient-management-high-tunnels

Fertilizer injector a Red Hawk Farm.
Photo Pam Dawling

and Fertigation in Organic Vegetable Production Systems

Fertilizers for Hoophouses

See the U of Minnesota Soil health and nutrient management in high tunnels. Hoophouse soils have particular nutrient management needs. The yield potential of hoophouse crops is usually 2-4 times more than outdoors. At higher yield potential, the need for nutrients naturally also increases. Adding organic matter (OM) to your soil as compost can improve its aggregate stability, and nutrient and water retention. Clay soils and those with high OM allow moisture to spread out from the drip emitters and the roots can extend farther. For this reason, all hoophouses need generous amounts of compost added to the soil at planting time. This is particularly important in sandy soils due to low water-holding capacity.

One of many wheelbarrows full of compost we spread every year.
Photo Wren Vile

However, too much compost can cause problems with water retention, especially if compost is left on the surface rather than incorporated, and can lead to high levels of phosphorus accumulation. Incorporate compost and manure into the soil rather than leaving it on the surface. This helps prevent compost from drying out on the soil surface and resisting water absorption. Some soil testing labs report finding granular fertilizers included in hoophouse soil samples submitted to them! Granular products do not get absorbed into hoophouse soil where drip irrigation is used.

Many growers start with a balanced fertilizer (a product containing equal amounts of nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium). They are often used alongside fertilizers providing only nitrogen, as relying only on balanced fertilizers will result in phosphorus build-up. Use plant-based composts rather than animal-based ones in hoophouses unless your soil is deficient in phosphorus. Even if no animal composts are used, phosphorus can build up.

Nitrogen Fertilizers for Organic Hoophouses

Here are three options for supplying adequate concentrated nitrogen to organic hoophouse crops. All provide readily available nitrogen, but can lead to salt build-up if applied in excess or if not mixed thoroughly into the soil.

  • Feather meal (13-0-0): This insoluble product does not work for fertigation or foliar applications.
  • Bloodmeal (12-0-0) and Fish emulsion (5-1-1): can be applied as a foliar spray, but may clog drip lines if applied via fertigation. Fish meal has a ratio of about 10-6-0. Some forms are water soluble, others not.

Legume Cover Crops for Hoophouses

Crimson clover cover crop with bumblebees.
Photo Bridget Aleshire

In addition to adding fertilizers, consider using cover crops and reducing tillage. Legume cover crops can supply nitrogen without increasing phosphorus levels. Legumes fix nitrogen from the air and gradually release it into the soil when the cover crop residues break down.

The University of Minnesota recommends the following legumes for their climate:

  • Fall planting: Austrian winter peas, hairy vetch
  • Winter planting (before your spring/summer crop): field peas, crimson clover
  • Summer planting: southern peas, crimson clover

Potassium Sources for Organic Hoophouses

Once fruiting starts, the need for potassium increases dramatically. Potassium sulfate or potassium magnesium sulfate are common in organic systems, and you can apply most of the potassium at planting and then side-dress the rest midway through the season. Potassium nitrate and potassium chloride are water-soluble and work well with fertigation systems, but are usually not allowed in organic systems.

Calcium and Magnesium Sources for Organic Hoophouses

If the soil pH is maintained in the optimum range of 6-7, calcium and magnesium are usually in sufficient amounts. Dolomitic lime supplies both Ca and Mg. If the soil pH is above 6, lime is not required, and gypsum (Ca-sulfate) and Ca-nitrate can be used to supply Ca.

Epsom salts (Mg-sulfate) and potassium magnesium sulfate will supply Mg without changing pH. Various sulfate compounds, such as gypsum, Epsom salts, potassium sulfate, and potassium magnesium sulfate, are sources of the secondary nutrient sulfur, and may be the amendment of choice if your soil needs acidification.

During the growing season, determine if your crops have enough nutrients. Learn more about tissue testing for fruit and vegetable growers. Expect to need to side-dress mid-season for long season crops like tomatoes.

 

ATTRA logo

ATTRA Soil Health Indicators and Tests, Table 1. Soil Health Tests

More Resources on Soil Health

eOrganic https://eorganic.org/

GFM Podcast: Episode #148 with Vern Grubinger from the University of Vermont.

Virginia Cooperative Extension Explanation of Soil Tests publication 452-701

ATTRA Soil Health Indicators and Tests

SARE Building Healthy Living Soils for Successful Organic Farming in the Southern Region

SARE Building Soils for Better Crops 4th edition

OFRF Soil Health and Organic Farming Building Organic Matter for Healthy Soils: An Overview

Pasa Soil Health Benchmarks Report 2021

Book Review: Water-Wise Gardening, Steve Solomon

Front cover of Water-Wise Gardening by Steve Solomon

Book Review

Water-Wise Gardening, Steve Solomon 2022, 191 pages, 6.1 x 0.5 x 9.2 inches. $18.99 on Amazon. Good Books Publishing.

This book started life as an 81-page paperback Gardening Without Irrigation: Or Without Much, Anyway, and evolved via the 1993 Water-Wise Vegetables: For the Maritime Northwest Gardener (Cascadia Gardening). When he was asked by Good Books if they could republish his work, Steve Solomon decided to expand and rewrite the book for most of North America, and to include wise use of irrigation. For those who don’t know, Cascadia (in Western Oregon) has almost no rainfall from June through September.

Solomon criticizes John Jeavons and the popular French Intensive close-planting bed system for depending on adequate or plentiful rainfall or irrigation without acknowledging that dependency. Gardening with only rainfall requires wider spacing and special planting techniques and schedules to take advantage of seasonal rain and store it in the soil as long as possible. Start weeding early in spring so that weeds do not compete for the stored water. Most moisture loss is transpiration from plant leaves, increased by evaporation from the soil.

There are also tips for those dealing with a sudden reduction in water supply (eg your well dries up): remove every other plant in the row, remove any undersown crops or cover crops, then shallowly hoe to make a dust mulch and fertigate if you can, as dryland gardeners are advised to do. Fertigation is a kind of “rich irrigation” of 2-10 gals/large plant per time, for a total of 50 gals/ plant.

A shallow dust mulch conserves water in the soil by preventing wicking of moisture from unworked soil below. Hoe every few days to maintain the dust. It needs to be restored after every rain, so clearly this method only works for dry climates, or dry seasons. I do wonder what this does ecologically – will the dust wash or blow away?

Spreading organic mulch after the soil has warmed up (not before as that slows plant growth) is another strategy. This book does not advocate weed-blocking thicknesses of 3″ or more, but a light coating to keep the moisture from evaporating. Hoeing under the mulch is possible.

Roots need oxygen, which is in decreasing supply the deeper they go, another natural limit to root depths in addition to moisture limitations. The book includes root drawings in Gardening When It Counts: Growing Food in Hard Times, copied by Muriel Chen from Root Development of Vegetable Crops, a 1927 book by John Weaver and William Bruner.

Steve Solomon, author of Water-Wise Gardening

Compacted soil has less air and is worth improving. If you have clay or compacted iron-rich sand below your topsoil, and you are energetic with lots of time, you can remove the topsoil and bust into the hard layer, mix in compost, then replace the topsoil on top. This is double-digging, and is not as fashionable as it once was.

Alternatively for clay soils, you can add lots of hi-calcium lime (not lime with magnesium in it) into the top 6″ (without raising the pH over 6.5) and then add smaller doses annually. Over time, the lime dissolves and washes into the lower soil, helping the clay flocculate.

Add 1″ of compost to new gardens and work it into the top 6″. Solomon is a fan of tilling. Add ½-1″ compost to the surface annually. Increasing the soil Organic Matter will improve the tilth and improve the water-holding capacity. Increasing the OM by 1% in the top 6″ can store an additional 40 gallons of water per 100 sq ft. Increases of 3-4% can provide as much as 200 extra gallons. This is not a linear equation. Adding more and more doesn’t increase the water capacity more and more. Your soil will stabilize at some OM level and adding more simply causes the soil to release nitrogen, especially in hot climates. Reaching 4% OM in steamy Arkansas can be as difficult as reaching 10% around Portland, Oregon. Green manures can help raise the OM for a few years, but then the extra N loss cancels the extra added.

Reduce runoff and help rain soak in by planting along contours rather than up and down the slope. Permanent mulch is not a good answer, if your frosts don’t go deeper, as populations of slugs, earwigs and pillbugs will increase.

Another aspect of dryland farming to bear in mind is: if your climate provides rain in spring and none in summer, your spring crops might use up all the water, making growing summer crops without irrigation impossible. One way to work with this problem is to grow more spring crops.

A way to avoid midsummer stunting caused by large plants running out of nutrients is to dig large 12″ deep planting holes, 12 sq ft apart, filling them with prepared fertile soil and making slight hills 16″ in diameter. Press five seeds into the soil at the center. This works for tomatoes, squash and big brassicas. Broccoli heads can grow the size of dinner plates with this method, provided you didn’t sow a “compact” variety. Hybrids do better than OP varieties, which have run downhill in recent years. This doesn’t sound practical for commercial growers, but can work well for backyard growers who like large plants.

Direct sowing has some advantages over transplanting, especially in terms of minimizing root damage, reducing the need to water. Another dryland grower told me that roots of direct-sown crops grow aligned with the foliage above ground. This matters most with vining crops and leads to the soil above the roots (i.e. below the leaves) losing less moisture.

West Indian Gherkin vines. Photo Nina Gentle

You could till the soil for your summer crops a month ahead of sowing, roll and then cover with a light mulch. To re-establish the capillarity of the soil you can roll a wheelbarrow over the positions for widely spaced rows and ignore the spaces in between.

It can help to soak seeds or even pre-sprout them just until roots start to emerge. Fluid sowing is another option. Pre-sprout the seeds for a few days and make a gel of 2-3 tablespoons of cornstarch in a pint of boiled water. After cooling it, try stirring in some seeds. If the mix is too watery to support them, heat up the gel and add more cornstarch. If too thick, add more water. Put the mix in a plastic bag and at your prepared furrow, snip a corner off the bag and squeeze out the gel.

For establishing winter crops, you can use an outdoor nursery seed bed to grow transplants to set out after the summer crops are finished.

The author provides his recipe for his Complete Organic Fertilizer (COF) to be used with ¼ -½” layer of compost each year. Provide a full dose of COF before planting anything, then side dress further from the stems with more COF every few weeks, up to a total of 6 additional quarts per 100 sq ft over the season. Foliar fertilizer sprays can also help, although the author disparages the Organic ones.

Reduced plant density is one of the keys to dryland gardening or farming. When plant canopies close above the ground, their roots underground are also meshing and competing for water. Lowering the plant density does not reduce the yield for the space as much as we might assume. A plant density of one-eighth that recommended for intensive planting might result in a yield of one-half of a dense planting. Plants at reduced spacing grow faster and bigger.

I found the recommended spacings quite startling! I grow vegetables in central Virginia, with a statistically even 3.5″ rain per month, and before that I gardened in Northern England, with a statistically similar rainfall. Solomon recommends transitioning to dry gardening by giving each plant 25% more area than you previously did, increasing that space by 25% each year until the plants stop getting bigger. If you are growing lots of a particular crop, you could speed things up by growing several rows, using different spacings.

Around this point in the book, I started to wonder why someone would choose dry gardening. It takes a lot of land, which has its price, and requires wide swathes of bare or lightly mulched soil. Why not invest in getting a well drilled? I know there are some places where underground water is not to be had, but I think that’s less common. Am I wrong?

The next part of the book is an A-Z of crops to grow. In a spirit of honesty and humility, the author admits to not knowing everything about every crop in every climate and asks for our patience.

Early Purple Sprouting Broccoli is ready for harvest in early spring and needs sowing in early fall.
Photo Baker Creek Seeds

Crops suitable for dry gardening include all the larger brassicas, but not the less vigorous smaller broccoli, quick-maturing cabbage and kohlrabi, early Brussels sprouts, or Chinese cabbage. Larger plants that have longer to grow are more likely to find enough soil moisture. Overwintered Purple Sprouting Broccoli is worth trying if your winters do not go much below 10F, perhaps zones 8a and milder. If winters are mild enough, try what in England are called spring cabbage or spring greens. Spring Hero is a good variety. Sow in late August or early September, transplant in fall, harvest in spring before or after heading.

Spring lettuce must be given a space of at least 12″ x 36″, up to a 36″ diameter circle. If you have no irrigation and are reliant on winter rain, you get one single chance to sow carrots in mid-spring. Perhaps counter-intuitively, the large autumn varieties are the ones to choose. They grow steadily as soil water allows, without getting fibrous. Make rows 4′ apart and thin to 6″ in-row. Wide spacing can lead to very large carrots, broccoli heads and potatoes, but the plants occupy the land for a long time. Is bigger always better?

Cucurbits don’t transplant easily due to root damage, and direct seeding doesn’t work if the soil is too cold or wet. Solomon has a strategy: Sow some squash first, as it is the cucurbit most tolerant of chilly, damp conditions. If the seeds don’t germinate in a week, sow some more. Continue until some germinate, then sow some cucumbers. Sow cucumbers once a week until you get some germination, then try some melons. To increase success with cucurbits, pre-sprout (chit) the seeds in a roll of damp paper or fabric towels. Don’t soak the seed first. Put the damp roll or sandwich in a plastic container in a warm place (75F/24C). Orient the seeds so the roots can obey gravity without looping, and start checking after 36 hours, and then every 8 hours. Plant the seeds in dampened soil in the garden before the roots are longer than the seed. Don’t water until the seedling emerges.

Potatoes grown in good fertile soil can contain 11% protein and taste delicious without ketchup or other additions. Supermarket potatoes contain around 8% protein. USDA nutritional studies over the past 50 years show that the average nutritional value of vegetables has declined 50%. In the early days of Idaho potato-growing, before irrigation added to the annual 10-15″ annual rainfall, growers set the seed pieces 18″ apart in rows 5′ apart. You can grow giant potatoes this way, and if you are short of seed potatoes and/or water, and need to feed a crowd, or fewer people for the full year, this may be the way to go.

Sweet potatoes are covered although the author has not personally grown them. Southern growers consider irrigation essential. Rutabagas are a challenge to grow without irrigation and do best sown in late June or early July, which is too late for those hoarding spring rain in the soil.

South Anna butternut winter squash. Photo Common Wealth Seed Growers

Squash roots can grow huge, including a deep taproot. Solomon advises giving each plant the amount of room the same as its maximum vine length, meaning a 10′ diameter circle for the bigger winter squash, and almost that for crookneck summer squash. If summer has no rain, yields of squash will be low unless you fertigate every 2-3 weeks. This will increase the yield by 45lbs.

Indeterminate tomatoes are suitable for dry gardening, because they have large root systems. Solomon adds stakes about 2′ apart in widening circles around each plant, to tie in the vines. They need about a 7′ diameter circle each.

The author is growing food for two people (oldies who don’t eat as much as they once did, as he points out). My impression is that this kind of gardening works for experienced gardeners growing on this kind of small scale. It doesn’t sound like it would work commercially.

The next chapter of the book gives the author’s own 60′ x 125′ ft garden plan from the 1990s, and some old photos. He has one 4′ wide 125′ long raised bed with 125′ single rows on either side. There are two lines of low-angle sprinklers along the edges of the raised bed. The reach of those is about 18′ and they each use 1gal/minute. They are 12′ apart. The raised bed is planted with crops that benefit most from irrigation.

The following section “How to make frugal and effective use of irrigation” includes a brief explanation of how soil is formed, what water does in the soil, and the hazards of over-watering (nutrients get washed down into the subsoil, along with oxygen), followed by tips on handwatering with a hose from John Jeavons, the intensive gardening expert, who advocates watering back and forth until the wet soil stays shiny for a certain length of time. I learned this as a 10-second rule, but, unsurprisingly, the time depends on your soil. Soloman suggests trying different ‘shine durations’ and then digging holes to see how deeply the soil is saturated. Once you know how long the shine lasts once you have got a suitable depth of watering, memorize your answer! Germinating seeds, young seedlings, new transplants and radishes need water most days.

Sprinklers can do the watering for you, freeing you from standing there with a hose. The author has a chart of how much moisture remains in the soil once plants have reached a permanent wilt stage (only 20-33%), a temporary wilt stage (50%), and the minimum for successful intensive vegetable beds (70%). There is another chart of the water needed to bring 12″ of soil from 70% to 100% capacity, and one of the average summertime daily soil moisture loss on non-rainy days (¼-½”). This helps you plan how often to water. How do you know when moisture has fallen below 70%? Take a handful of soil and form a ball. If it is wet, it’s over 70%. If it sticks together but breaks apart under thumb pressure, it’s around 70%. If you can’t form a ball, it’s below 65%. If the soil is sandy, you won’t ever be able to form a ball.

One of our impact sprinkler tripods, in a (not wide-spaced) broccoli and cabbage patch.
Photo Pam Dawling

Sprinklers may not distribute water evenly, so test those you already have, and buy good agricultural-quality ones in future. Determine your water pressure and flow rate (time filling a 5-gal bucket). Suitable impact sprinkler nozzles should emit 1.25-2.5gals/min. Rainbird 14VH is a recommended type for vegetable growers. It comes with a range of nozzle sizes. The book has charts of nozzle sizes with the corresponding throw radius at various water pressure rates, along with gals/min distributed. Another chart shows application rates from various sized nozzles and two representative pressure rates.  Small bore nozzles and application rates up to ½” per hour generally work well for vegetable gardens.

To achieve an even application rate over the whole of the area irrigated, a rotating impact sprinkler must deposit around nine times as much water around its periphery as at its center. Most growers devise a system of overlapping circles to even things out. To water a smaller radius, various diffuser flaps and adjustable screws can be used to interrupt the flow, but these make distribution less even.  Models without these devices are made that put only twice as much water at the center as at the periphery. Avoid the bells and whistles you don’t need.

High-angle sprinklers throw a greater distance than low-angle ones. Choose high-angle sprinklers with 1/16″ nozzles to run all night on clay soils, minimizing evaporation, and getting good value for the water applied. Nelson makes turbine-powered designs that provide even coverage for a fair price. The book has good drawings of different sprinklers.

You can get more and better drip irrigation information elsewhere. Solomon seems to believe that a 100′ length of drip tape has to be trashed if it gets one cut. This definitely isn’t the case. It sounds like he just never learned to like drip tape.

The last chapter consists of charts of suggested plant spacings based on the author’s direct experience and informed guesses. The reading list includes 16 classical Western texts from 1920 to 1992.

This book is one of about 15 by Steve Solomon, some reissued with new titles. His most well-known work, Growing Vegetables West of the Cascades, has been published in seven editions, 1983 to 2015. I liked Gardening When It Counts: Growing Food in Hard Times (2006) but was not alone in disliking the superior tone in The Intelligent Gardener: Growing Nutrient-Dense Food (2012). I’m glad he has mellowed.