Unusual Crop for November – Perennial onions

Egyptian Onions. photo Southern Exposure Seed Exchange

Unusual Crop for November – Perennial onions and other less common alliums

This month, I’m writing about unusual perennial onions and other less common alliums. Also see my blog series Alliums for the month, and chapter 51 Unusual Alliums in Sustainable Market Farming, 2nd edition. That chapter has an Allium Calendar chart for sowing, transplanting, dividing and replanting, harvesting and storing 15 types of alliums.

Plant various perennial alliums in October and November

  1. Shallots (Allium cepa var. aggregatum) Plant shallot bulbs between October and November, if your winters aren’t too cold. Mulch them well. We tried to over-winter replanted bulbs, but we got lots of winter-kill. To save bulbs for replanting in early spring, refrigerate them. You can alternatively start shallots from seed in late January in zone 7 and plant in spring. Shallots have a delicate, mild flavor and some varieties are especially valued in gourmet cooking. Southern Exposure Seed Exchange shallots are widely adapted and do not require special daylight lengths to yield well.

    French Red Shallot bulbs. Photo Raddysh Acorn
  2. Plant medium-sized potato onions (Allium cepa var. aggregatum) (1.5″-2″, 4-5 cm) at the end of November or early December in zone 7.  Save the small ones to plant in January, as they won’t survive the winter well in the ground. On the plus side, the small ones store really well indoors, unlike the large ones. While some gardeners find seed onions to be an easy, productive crop others struggle with them. If you’re having a hard time with seed onions perennial onions are worth a shot. There’s more information about Potato onions and shallots in the Perennial Onion Growing Guide from Southern Exposure Seed Exchange. 

    A yellow potato onion plant in spring, showing how a cluster of onions forms. Photo Kathryn Simmons

  3. L’itoi (Allium cepa var. aggregatum) is a tiny purple shallot-like perennial onion. See the Slow Food Ark of Taste. This peppery little perennial clumping onion is named after the mountain regarded by the O’odham Nation as the navel of the world, where it was perhaps brought to the US by Jesuit missionaries in the late 17th century. The plant thrives in the Southwest deserts. It dies back in summer and then re-sprouts toward the end of the season, when it is harvested, divided and replanted.


  4. Red marble cipollini from Johnny’s Seeds

    Pickling onions (cipollini) (Allium cepa var. cepa), are (like bulb onions and scallions) a biennial crop grown as an annual. Spring-planted cipollini (we sow 1/25 in Virginia). Red Marble is good, stores well. Purplette doesn’t store well. White ones get sunburn here.

    Pearl Onions from Rural Sprout
  5. Pearl onions (Allium ampeloprasum var. sectivum), also known as creamers in the US (or possibly Minogue onions), or button or baby onions in the UK, are a close relative of the leek. They may be distinguished from bulb onions by not having layers of storage leaves but only a single storage corm, similar to the non-layered cloves of garlic. Pearl Onions originated in central to southern Europe and are a minor crop in several countries, especially the Netherlands, Germany and Italy. Pearl Onions are herbaceous, perennial plants producing 6-9 leaves 10-30 cm (4-12″) long sheathed around a flowering scape 45-180 cm (18-72″) tall, growing from an underground bulb. The bulb divides and produces a large cluster of fairly large bulbils up to 30 mm (1″) in diameter, forming in time a cluster of plants. Plants are usually divided once dormant in the fall and immediately replanted.

Pearl onions prefer a dry, sunny position in a light well-drained soil, but can succeed in clay soils, and can tolerate a pH from 5.2 to 8.3. The bulbs should be planted 2.5-4 cm (1-1½”) deep. In areas with mild winters, they can be planted in late autumn or early winter; elsewhere they are planted in early spring. Pearl onions can be grown as an annual crop, or be left in the ground for an extra year to grow larger. Removing the flower-head as soon as it starts to develop (or letting it grow 30 cm (12″) tall then harvesting it for food) will usually result in more of the plant’s energy going into making the bulb and therefore larger bulbs. The onions are ready to harvest 60-90 days from sowing. They have thin skins and a mild, sweet flavor, and grow up to 1″ (2.5 cm) in diameter. They are used as a vegetable and are mostly used for pickling. Most of the onions grown for pickling today are simply small crowded (layered) bulb onions. The plant also has a range of medicinal uses (it has an action rather like a mild garlic).

  1. Perennial leeks (Allium ampeloprasum), aka Oepri, Perlzwiebel, or possibly Minogue onions, can be dug as leeks when they are large enough or used as scallions while small. They take 9-12 months to grow to a good size. Plant perennial leeks from dry bulbs from August-November, a month earlier than divisions. Divide clumps and replant in late September through November and March-April. In June, July and early August some people use the larger bulbils in mixed pickles. See Alliums for December.
Elephant Garlic. Photo Raddysh Acorn
  1. Elephant Garlic (Allium ampeloprasum var. ampeloprasum), looks like a giant garlic head, tastes like a mild garlic, can be used in place of garlic, but it’s actually a leek – not garlic. Some people prefer the milder flavor, especially when it is served raw, such as in salads and salad dressings. The flower heads can also be cooked as a vegetable. A bulb can grow as large as 3½” (9 cm) in diameter and weigh up to 6½ oz (184 gm).
  2. Kurrat (Allium ampeloprasum kurrat group) is a Middle-Eastern cultivated leek, growing to 1 m (39“). It prefers moist soil, but will not grow in shade. It is used mainly for the greens that may be cut from the plant repeatedly, but the bulb part is also edible.

  3. Egyptian onions, (previously considered Allium cepa var. proliferum. Now, according to Wikipedia, they are known to be a hybrid of A. cepa and A. fistulosum,) aka top-setting onions, tree onions, or walking onions. They produce tiny red-purple bulbs in the umbel instead of flowers. Divide the clumps in spring (March, April) and fall (late September to November depending on your climate). Harvest the green leaves September-April, whenever they are big enough.

  4. Perennial Rakkyo (Allium Chinense), aka true pearl onions (confusingly), Japanese scallions, Vietnamese leeks or Chinese onions. The plant has rose pink flowers, crisp, mild-flavored bulbs and delicate chive-like foliage. The small bulbs are generally pickled. It is a perennial herb closely related to garlic and onions, yet with its own distinct flavor profile, making it a favorite in various culinary traditions.
  5. Welsh onions (Allium fistulosum) are native to Siberia or China, not Wales. They are also known as Japanese bunching onions, cibol, chibbles (in Cornwall), escallions (in Jamaica), negi (in Japan), pa (in Korea), as well as green onions, salad onions, spring onions. These general last names are also used for other kinds of onions when the leaves are the part eaten. Young plants of Welsh onions and bulb onions look very similar but can be distinguished by their leaves, which are all hollow and circular in cross-section in Welsh onions (fistulosum means “hollow”), never flattened on one side. Plants tolerate a variety of soil types, and do best in well-drained, sandy-limey loam in full sun to part shade, in zones 6-9. In climates colder than Zone 6, shallots are typically grown as an annual. To do this, sow seeds in early spring for summer use. Plant 1/4″-1/2″ (6-12 mm) apart and ½” (1 cm) deep. Welsh onions do not develop bulbs. From late May to August they grow scapes (flowering stalks) 24“-36“ (60 cm to 1 m) tall, each stalk being topped by a round umbel (to 3” (8 cm) diameter) consisting of 50-100 tiny, yellowish-white flowers.

    Allium Vineale, Onion grass. Photo NC State Extension
  6. Onion grass in Virginia (Allium vineale), aka wild garlic or crow garlic. The leaves of onion grass are hollow and round.

  7. Canada onion (Allium canadense), aka wild onion is a perennial sounding very like what we call onion grass or wild garlic in Virginia, although there are differences. While the leaves of Allium vineale are hollow and round, those of Canada onion are more flat and solid.

  8. Ramps (Allium tricoccum) are a native perennial of Eastern North America that can be wildcrafted sustainably or raised in a woodland. See Unusual Crop for October

    Ramsons Wild Garlic flowers in May. Photo Galloway Wild Foods
  9. Ramsons (Allium ursinum), aka buckrams, wild garlic, broad-leaved garlic, wood garlic, bear leek, or bear’s garlic, is common in Europe. The leaves are broad and flat, lance-shaped. The flowers are white. All parts of the plant are edible. It thrives in shady damp woods, and it is used as an ancient woodland indicator species (its presence alone does not prove that a woodland is ancient). It looks like ramps (Allium tricoccum) but is not the same.

  10. Field garlic (Allium oleraceum) is native to most of Europe, where it is a wild perennial, growing tall leaves (the part that is used).

Resources

Harvesting Alliums (onions, garlic and relatives)

Onions curing and drying in strings.
Credit Southern Exposure Seed Exchange

The allium family includes all kinds of onions, garlic, leeks, perennial onions such as potato onions, and also less well known alliums, mostly perennials.

This is the time of year for harvesting most alliums except leeks. (It’s the time for planting out leeks for fall and winter harvests.)

I have a whole series of Alliums for the month posts. Here’s a link to Alliums for June. It includes the starter for the list I provide here, of the relative timing of harvests for various alliums.

Order of Allium Harvests

Our allium harvests generally occur on these dates. Your dates will differ but you can expect this order of harvests:

  1. Nov 18–May 10: Onion scallions in the hoophouse
  2. Mar 15–May 31: Garlic scallions
  3. May 7–May 28: Garlic scapes
  4. May 10–Jun 30: Onion scallions outdoors
  5. May 25–Jun 10: Green bulb onions (Allium cepa)
  6. May 30–Jun 8: Hardneck garlic
  7. May 30–Jun 11: Potato onions ( cepa aggregatum) planted in fall
  8. Jun 6–Jun 25: Potato onions planted in January and February
  9. Jun 10: Shallot bulbs (cepa aggregatum), fall-planted. They are not fully hardy in zone 7a. I recommend storing bulbs and replanting in early spring instead
  10. Jun 11–Jun 12: Softneck garlic bulbs
  11. Jun 11–Jul 11: Bulb onions sown in fall, with slow spring-sown ones to Jul 26
  12. Jun 19–Jul 2: Cipollini (cepa cepa) Small bulb onions grown in a hoophouse from spring transplants
  13. Jun 30–Jul 5: Elephant garlic ( ampeloprasum ampeloprasum) We stopped growing this when too many winter-killed
  14. Jul 1–Jul 8: Shallots from bulbs refrigerated over the winter and replanted in early spring
  15. Jul 1–Jul 15: Cipollini outdoors from spring transplants
  16. July: L’itoi (A. cepa aggregatum). This peppery little perennial clumping onion sends up edible shoots in early July.
  17. Jul 4–Jul 30: Shallots from seed started in late January, plugs transplanted in March. Harvest 4–8 weeks later than those from bulbs replanted in October
  18. July–September: The small red-purple bulbils of Egyptian onions can be pickled. Earlier in the year, before the bulbils appear, harvest the tasty, succulent leaves of this very hardy perennial.
  19. Spring, summer, fall according to size: Welsh onions ( A. fistulosum) are non-bulbing, hardy perennial onion greens, larger than chives and scallions. Japanese bunching onions are similar. Can be sown in fall or spring. Clumps can be divided and replanted
  20. Sep 6: Shallots direct sown outdoors in February and March

Here’s some details on harvesting some of the smaller alliums

Harvesting onion scallions

Scallions ready-to-harvest.
Photo Pam Dawling

From around May 10, through June, our outdoor onion scallions are big enough to harvest (just as the hoophouse ones finish up!) We start these from seed in January and February and transplant as clumps in March and April. In cooler climates, you can schedule harvests through summer, but we cannot get good quality ones here after late June. It’s good to develop an efficient harvest method with little scallions or it takes way too long. To harvest, loosen the soil with a digging fork, then lift out a clump. Deal with scallions in bunches as much as possible, rather than one at a time. Shake the plants, and trim off the roots and the ragged tips. Holding the bunch in one hand, pass the scallions one at a time to the other hand, separating them and pulling off a single outer leaf, not more. Don’t fuss with them too much. Next set the scallions in water in a small bucket, to clean themselves while you work on the rest. If you are going to band them, start out with a bunch of rubber bands around three fingers on the hand that holds the bunches (leaving the forefinger free for tasks demanding dexterity). When you’re ready to band them, use the other hand to pull a rubber band into position. When the bucket is full enough, dunk the scallions up and down, and transfer them to a clean bucket with a small amount of water to keep them fresh.

Harvesting garlic scallions

A healthy patch of garlic scallions in spring
Photo credit Kathryn Simmons

Garlic scallions (small whole garlic plants) provide our first allium harvest of the calendar year, starting in mid-late March and continuing (if we have planted enough) into May. Some people cut the greens at 10″ (25 cm) tall and bunch them, allowing cuts to be made every two or three weeks. We prefer to simply lift the whole plant once it reaches about 7″–8″ (18–20 cm) tall. You may need to loosen the plants rather than just pulling. The leaves keep in better condition if still attached to the clove. Trim the roots, rinse, bundle, set in a small bucket with a little water, and you’re done! Garlic scallions can be sold in bunches of three to six depending on size.

Harvesting garlic scapes

Harvesting garlic scapes
Photo by Wren Vile

Another spring allium harvest is garlic scapes (the firm, edible flower stems of hardneck garlic).  Here scapes appear when tulip poplars flower. In a warm spring, that can be the end of April. Garlic scape arrival is partly temperature dependent. We harvest scapes two or three times a week for about three weeks, until there are no more. At the Roxbury Agriculture Institute at Philia Farm in New York State, they wait until the scape has curled round, then cut it off. We harvest ours sooner than that, in order to let the bulb grow as big as possible. We pull our garlic scapes to get the most out ! In our climate, the appearance of scapes indicates the garlic will be ready to harvest in three weeks. I’m not sure if the same timing works everywhere, so keep records and you’ll learn what to expect. Exactly how day-length and temperature interact as triggers for scape and bulb harvest dates, I don’t know. I’ve done some research, but haven’t found much solid info yet.  In general, plant flowering is triggered by some combination of enough vernalization (chilling hours — maybe 10 weeks below 40°F/4.5°C), plant maturity, temperature and photo-period (the relative length of day and night). In cold weather the plants suppress the flowering signal. The leaves perceive the amount of daylight, and when the temperature is also right, they trigger flowering by sending a signal (called Florigen) to the shoot tips. Florigen may be an actual compound, or may be some combination or ratio of several hormones produced by the plant. Almost all these factors are outside our control once the plant is in the ground, so the best we can do is pay attention and be ready to act.

Harvest garlic bulbs and bulbing onions

(see Alliums for June) I won’t go into details here, as I’ve done that previously.

240 heads of garlic drying in Tenax fencing.
Photo Sierran Farmer

Harvest small potato onions

produced by large ones planted in September.

Yellow Potato Onions.
Photo Southern Exposure Seed Exchange

Harvesting cipollini

(aka cocktail onions, boiling onions, pickling onions)

Red Marble cipollini.
Photo Fedco Seeds

These small, attractive onion bulbs can be easier to grow in marginal onion climates than full-sized onions or can be an additional allium crop. The larger ones can be used as fresh bunching onions. All may be cured. Cipollini naturally have more sugar than most onions, which makes them ideal for caramelizing or roasting whole. The scheduling and final size of your cipollini will depend on your latitude and temperatures.