Tokyo Bekana as a Summer Lettuce Substitute

An adolescent Tokyo bekana plant.
Photo Pam Dawling

I know I’ve mentioned previously that the Asian greens known as Tokyo bekana and maruba santoh can make a good substitute for lettuce in hot weather. We’re doing this right now, in July and August, after suffering lettuce failure due to cutworms.

Germinate Lettuce Outdoors With Ice

Until mid-July, I managed to get the lettuce growing well in the outdoor nursery seedbed, as I’ve described HERE, using ice cubes, but noticed the number of seedlings was declining each day!

If using a nursery seed bed, you can put ice cubes on top of rows of seeds in hot weather to help cool the soil.
Photo Bell Oaks

Germinate Lettuce in Flats Outdoors or In

My first response was to sow lettuce seed in Winstrip 50- and 72-cell flats outdoors on a mesh cart, so the plants were out of reach of the cutworms (which live in the soil). I used scraps of shadecloth over the flats and watered several times a day.

A 50-cell Winstrip tray sown with lettuce seed.
Photo Pam Dawling

For those determined to do better with lettuce, I wrote this post Lettuce Growing Tips.

Tokyo Bekana Grows Fast

I realized though, that even if this scheme worked, we’d have a gap of two-three weeks with no lettuce, so I also prepped the bed the lost lettuce would have been transplanted into, and the same day I sowed the flats of lettuce, I sowed Tokyo bekana in the ground. I did the same five days later when it was time to sow more lettuce. Brassicas come up well in hot soil, and grow faster than lettuce, so I thought I could make up for lost time. From emergence to full-size harvest in warm weather is 45 days.

Everything I say here about Tokyo bekana also applies to maruba santoh, it’s just that as they are so similar, we decided to only grow Tokyo bekana, for simplicity. Tokyo bekana and maruba santoh are non-heading greens in a category known in English as celery cabbage.  They don’t taste like celery, but have broad white stems, which I’m guessing is where they got that name. The leaves are a light golden green color (chartreuse), very similar to bibb lettuces and Salad Bowl oakleaf lettuce. The flavor is very mild and the texture is tender. They can easily pass for lettuce. In some hot countries such as Jamaica and Cuba, they are grown and sold as Summer Lettuce.

Maruba Santoh
Photo by Ethan Hirsh

Station-Sowing in the Garden

Because we had not planned this crop and I didn’t want to use a lot of seed, I station-sowed the Tokyo bekana. I used the row-marker rake to draw 4 parallel lines. These little furrows were deep enough for the small Tokyo bekana seeds. I aimed to drop 2 or 3 seeds every 12” (30cm) in each row, planning to single the seedlings to one every 12” later. I did a fairly quick-and-dirty job, estimating the spacing by using my feet as landmarks. About a week later I sowed the second half of the space in the same way.

Direct sown Tokyo bekana seedlings under ProtekNet. Photo Pam Dawling

On day 12 since the first sowing, I singled the seedlings. Ideally I would have done it sooner, as they were already 2-3” tall.  I removed the roots and saved the tops for salad. Ideally, I would have hoed around those plants today, but it was horribly hot out there. The second sowing were up, and maybe ¾” across.

I managed to get them all hoed before Tropical Storm Debby came in, August 8.

Young direct-sown Tokyo bekana seedlings in need of hoeing. Photo Pam Dawling

Tokyo bekana and maruba santoh need generous watering, 2” (5 cm) per week in hot weather, maybe even more. If your plants start to bolt, harvest immediately and do not despair. Bolting Asian greens do not get bitter as bolting lettuce does. Cut them into small pieces and mix with whatever other salad crops you have.

It looks like my plan will work fairly well. Two-three weeks later I’m looking at a declining amount of lettuce, maybe two weeks’ worth, and increasing sizes of Tokyo bekana, which might reach big-enough in two weeks. Not full-size, but big enough to harvest the outer leaves, which will keep the plants alive and growing more leaves!

Netted Tokyo bekana grown for salad in a time of lettuce shortage. August 13.
Photo Pam Dawling

These greens can be harvested by cutting the whole plant, or by taking individual leaves from as many plants as you need, to get enough. If supplies are short, take individual leaves, and the plants will all continue to grow.

Tokyo Bekana Survives Down to 8F

Now it’s really dead! Tokyo bekana after two nights at 8F.
Photo Pam Dawling

Tokyo bekana also has a fair amount of cold-tolerance, for those of you with a short growing season.