
At the Virginia Association for Biological Farming conference a couple of weeks ago, I attended a lot of useful workshops. Dr Tom Kuhar, Professor and Vegetable Entomology Specialist at Virginia Tech, talked about which OMRI-approved insecticides actually work for which pests. Organic methods are more interesting to him, as they require more understanding of insects. Assume any errors here are made by me, not Tom Kuhar.

Try non-chemical control options first
Dr Kuhar started by reminding us to try non-chemical control options first: resistant variety selection, cultural control (agronomic strategies, like changing planting dates, crop rotation), physical control (exclude the pests with netting, rowcover, kaolin clay etc), biological control (predators and parasites).
Chemical control (synthetic substances) should be the last resort (because of collateral damage). Organic insecticides have some limitations and problems: they are usually short-lived, and require frequent applications; they require attention to getting complete plant coverage and sometimes precise timing; they have no systemic activity and often a short shelf life; they may be expensive and, lastly, there is not always good information about their efficacy (and false myths abound!)
Soft-bodied insects
Diatomaceous Earth is a crushed rock that is abrasive to crawling insects and absorbs liquids, drying them out. It doesn’t work on fungus gnats or moths. Be careful handling diatomaceous earth, wear a good dust mask, as it can damage lungs. It also dries out your skin if handled without gloves. It only works on contact, so if it gets washed away by rain, it no longer works!

Pesticidal oils smother eggs and nymphs of mites and scale insects and are effective on other soft-bodied insects like aphids, thrips, whiteflies and psyllids. They generally provide longer control than soaps, and like soaps, they can cause phytotoxicity. Read the ingredients, some are plant-based, some fish oil based, others are petroleum products. Look for the OMRI symbol. Trilogy is a 70% extract of neem oil.
Pesticidal Soaps such as M-Pede, DES-X, Safer brands and Concern are potassium or ammonium salts of fatty acids. They provide short-term partial control of aphids, mealybugs, whiteflies, mites and other soft-bodied insects. It is necessary to get very good plant coverage, hopefully insect coverage. The soap disrupts the cuticle of the insect. It doesn’t work on hard-bodied insects, despite the pictures of a grasshopper and a harlequin bug on the Safer jug. At high temperatures soaps can cause phytotoxicity (damage to the plant tissues).
Deer can be deterred by insecticidal soap!

Photo Pam Dawling
A surprise for many of us is that insecticidal soaps can deter deer for a week or two, even after one rain! With a big patch of corn, it can work to spray just a border around the corn – you’ll have to experiment (and let the rest of know), with how wide of a border for what size of corn patch.
Botanical Extracts
Next are botanical extracts, essential oils of rosemary, peppermint, clove, cinnamon, and citrus peel. They work as antifeedants or repellents short-term and give fair-to-good action against spider mites. If with adjuvants (often soaps or oils as spreader-stickers) they can be effective on aphids.
Neem extracts are oils, soaps and other extracts containing azadirachtin. They are made from seeds of the tropical neem tree, and work by interfering with insect molting. Hence they are most effective on young insect stages.
Pyrethrins and combos
Pyrethrins are made from dried flowers of pyrethrum daisies. It is a contact poison providing a good, but very short-lived knockdown for a lot of different pests. Not usually worth buying because sunlight and insects break it down quickly.

Azera is a combination of pyrethrum and azadirachtin (Neem) that is more effective than pyrethrum alone against leafhoppers, cucumber beetles, aphids and caterpillars. Azera is no longer on the market, but apparently you can mix your own (I haven’t got a recipe).
Spinosad (Entrust) is a fermented product of a tropical soil microorganism. It is very effective against caterpillars, fly larvae, thrips and Colorado potato beetle larvae. It can provide fair-good control of flea beetles and Mexican bean beetles. It does not provide good control of aphids, whiteflies, leafhoppers, true bugs or other sucking insects. Use spinosad for listed insects if soaps have not worked. There is a (low) limit on how often you should spray spinosad on the same area.
Trials on 22 different crop/pest combinations
Dr. Galen Dively, Professor Emeritus of the University of Maryland has conducted over 186 trials on 22 different crop/pest combinations. His teams have evaluated the efficacy, rates and timings of registered and experimental organic insecticides. You can read his work on ResearchGate.
Trials comparing the efficacy of Azera, Entrust, Pyganic and Neemix
For flea beetles, Azera, Pyganic and Entrust are more effective than Neemix.
For cucumber beetles, Azera, Neemix and Pyganic were more effective than Entrust (spinosad).

For Colorado potato beetles, Entrust was most effective, Azera and Neemix were more effective than Pyganic.
For imported cabbage worm, Entrust worked best, then Azera, followed by Pyganic, with Neemix last of the four.
For potato leafhopper, Azera and Pyganic were the most effective, but not Neemix, or Entrust.
For thrips on tomatoes, Entrust worked best at reducing the number of thrips per 5 leaves in June, but the percentage of thrips-damaged fruit at harvest was least when Azadirachtin was used. The other pesticides used in this trial were Ecotec (essential oils) and Pyganic.
For thrips on onion, cutflower and tomato in a different trial, Entrust worked best (but not grreat), with Azera, Neemix and Entrust at similar slightly lower levels.

(Photo: J. Obermeyer Purdue Extension)
For corn earworm, Entrust was by far the best (7% damaged ears), but was used in the trial at a not-allowed rate of 8 sprays, while Neemix, Pyganic and the untreated control plants all suffered 91.5-94.5 percent damaged ears. Trichogramma wasps can be effective. Gemstar (a virus) works very well.
Another study compared Efficacy of Common Active Ingredients in Organic Insecticides Against Difficult to Control Insect Pests. Corn earworm has developed resistance to Bt, because of the GMO corn. Bt of both the kurstaki and aizawai strains did little against corn earworm, even after 7 sprays. Bt has a short shelf life unless refrigerated. It requires ingestion by a susceptible insect to be effective, and breaks down in sunlight.

T. Schwarz, NC State University
Grandevo (Chromobacterium substugae), Venerate and Majestene (Burkholderia spp) are bacteria-derived insecticides that must be ingested to kill sucking insects, mites, flies and some chewing insects. So far, field trials have not shown good results on hard-to-kill insects. Grandevo does cut the number of lygus bugs by half. Majestene has been shown to reduce root knot nematode galls on tomatoes, and wireworms in potatoes.
Beauveria bassiana fungal insecticide works well on small Cpb larvae, but not wireworms.
For nightshade flea beetle, Azera, Entrust, Seican (a fungicide, insecticide, and miticide derived from cinnamon), TetraCURB Max (Miticide, Insecticide & Repellent made from castor oil, rosemary oil, clove oil and peppermint oil), PFR-97® 20% WDG (a fungus contact insecticide), and BoteGHA ES (Beauveria) all work. PFR and Seican are not labeled for use against flea beetles.

Stink bugs are among the hardest for Organic growers to kill. Ten organic pesticides have been tried without success. Surround (kaolin) does work, giving 50% less insect damage. Kaolin is a clay powder to mix with water and coat the plants to prevent insect attack. It washes off with rain and then must be reapplied. It needs careful washing to remove it from produce before sale. Sprayers must be carefully cleaned and some gaskets may get ruined by the powder. Kaolin also works against plum curculio, caterpillars, aphids on fruit, mites and leafhoppers.
We buy our pest management products (and cover crop seeds) from Seven Springs Farm Supply, in Floyd, Virginia
